Uploaded image for project: 'Jira Data Center'
  1. Jira Data Center
  2. JRASERVER-3406

Threaded Comments

XMLWordPrintable

    • 103
    • 20
    • Hide
      Atlassian Update – 30 March 2018

      Hi everyone,

      Thanks for your interest in this issue.
      This request is considered a potential addition to our longer-term roadmap.

      We'll typically review this request in about 12 months time, at which point we’ll consider whether we need to alter its status.

      For the nearest future we've decided to prioritize other areas of the Jira Server roadmap, including:

      • Performance and stability improvements
      • Archiving projects for improved performance
      • Optimising the use of custom fields
      • Improving performance of boards
      • Improving Jira notifications
      • Allowing users to edit shared filters and dashboards
      • Mobile app for Jira Server

      You can also try a free marketplace add-on available for this functionality: Threaded Comments for Jira.

      You can learn more about our approach to highly voted server suggestions here.

      To learn more on how your suggestions are reviewed, see our updated workflow for server feature suggestions.

      Kind regards,
      Jira Server Product Management

      Show
      Atlassian Update – 30 March 2018 Hi everyone, Thanks for your interest in this issue. This request is considered a potential addition to our longer-term roadmap. We'll typically review this request in about 12 months time, at which point we’ll consider whether we need to alter its status. For the nearest future we've decided to prioritize other areas of the Jira Server roadmap, including: Performance and stability improvements Archiving projects for improved performance Optimising the use of custom fields Improving performance of boards Improving Jira notifications Allowing users to edit shared filters and dashboards Mobile app for Jira Server You can also try a free marketplace add-on available for this functionality:  Threaded Comments for Jira. You can learn more about our  approach to highly voted server suggestions here . To learn more on how your suggestions are reviewed, see our  updated workflow for server feature suggestions . Kind regards, Jira Server Product Management
    • We collect Jira feedback from various sources, and we evaluate what we've collected when planning our product roadmap. To understand how this piece of feedback will be reviewed, see our Implementation of New Features Policy.

      NOTE: This suggestion is for JIRA Server. Using JIRA Cloud? See the corresponding suggestion.

      Original request description

      Instead of having just a simple linear comment tree, how about being able to have an (optional) threaded view where replies to comments and replies to replies could be seen as such.

      The option to allow threaded comments, linear comments or even comments at all could be on an issue by issue basis as well as having project / global defaults which you could fall back on (if unselected).

            [JRASERVER-3406] Threaded Comments

            Michael Mohr added a comment - - edited

            Sorry , but a commercial app with addl. costs can't be the answer to all feature requests. we are paying every year more and more money for the Atlassian application but seems not to get new features for this money.

            The for sure cool threaded comment app would cost us yearly addl 14000 USD a year. But  This add only really will not have a ROI for us

            So let us celebrate the 20th anniversary of this enhancement request wi with such high costs.th on more then 1000 voters. so why in the hell should Atlassian react to this, as neither the 20 years north more then 1000 requesting customers seems to change their opinion on what is important for their customers. 

            This is here the same bad discussion as with the enhancement request of history for comments without that comment are not auditable while Iso audits.

            Michael Mohr added a comment - - edited Sorry , but a commercial app with addl. costs can't be the answer to all feature requests. we are paying every year more and more money for the Atlassian application but seems not to get new features for this money. The for sure cool threaded comment app would cost us yearly addl 14000 USD a year. But  This add only really will not have a ROI for us So let us celebrate the 20th anniversary of this enhancement request wi with such high costs.th on more then 1000 voters. so why in the hell should Atlassian react to this, as neither the 20 years north more then 1000 requesting customers seems to change their opinion on what is important for their customers.  This is here the same bad discussion as with the enhancement request of history for comments without that comment are not auditable while Iso audits.

            John Roberts-Davies added a comment - - edited

            Atlassian, please consider including this within the standard license.
            Target Process includes this functionality out of the box, and this functionality is a common expectation for such a premium priced product as Jira.

            John Roberts-Davies added a comment - - edited Atlassian, please consider including this within the standard license. Target Process includes this functionality out of the box, and this functionality is a common expectation for such a premium priced product as Jira.

            Peter Muldoon added a comment -

            Threaded Comments for Jira
            is the recognised marketplace leader for effective team communication and now has 183,000 + satisfied users  
            the app will save your team hours of effort, improve productivity and save your enterprise big bucks

            The app is available on Cloud & Data Centre 

            Check it out here:-  https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145

            We release a new version every alternate month, and welcome your suggestions

            Peter Muldoon added a comment - Threaded Comments for Jira is the recognised marketplace leader for effective team communication and now has 183,000 + satisfied users   the app will save your team hours of effort, improve productivity and save your enterprise big bucks The app is available on Cloud & Data Centre   Check it out here:-   https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145 We release a new version every alternate month, and welcome your suggestions

            Peter Muldoon added a comment -

            We have released Version 1.49.0 of Threaded Comments for Jira - Data Centre - 9.16.1 on 21st June, 2024
             
            The latest release includes:-

            • Updated the filtering and sort buttons with new icons to streamline the icons and buttons above the comment threads. 
            • Removed the ability to filter and add comments from the bottom of the page 
            • The comment box now floats from the top of the comments, not the bottom 
            • Tidied up the button alignment in the text editor box 
            • Improved the sorting of threads, by retaining the time stamp of deleted parent comments 
            • Removed the ability to collapse a comment without any replies to it in an effort to clean up the UI and remove unnesseccary functionality 
            • Fixed a bug where Heading 1 text was appearing centred in the activity feed - it's now left-aligned 
            • Fixed a bug that was sending customers email notifications for internal responses in Jira Service Management 
            • Tidied up the admin settings to bring it in line with the new UI updates.
            • Cleaned up the UI and remove un-necessary functionality 
               
              Check it out here:- https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145/threaded-comments-for-jira?hosting=datacenter&tab=versions
               
              We welcome your feedback and suggestions to further improve the functionality of the app
               
              Regards
              Peter, votazz Support Team

            Peter Muldoon added a comment - We have released Version 1.49.0 of Threaded Comments for Jira - Data Centre - 9.16.1 on 21st June, 2024   The latest release includes:- Updated the filtering and sort buttons with new icons to streamline the icons and buttons above the comment threads.  Removed the ability to filter and add comments from the bottom of the page  The comment box now floats from the top of the comments, not the bottom  Tidied up the button alignment in the text editor box  Improved the sorting of threads, by retaining the time stamp of deleted parent comments  Removed the ability to collapse a comment without any replies to it in an effort to clean up the UI and remove unnesseccary functionality  Fixed a bug where Heading 1 text was appearing centred in the activity feed - it's now left-aligned  Fixed a bug that was sending customers email notifications for internal responses in Jira Service Management  Tidied up the admin settings to bring it in line with the new UI updates. Cleaned up the UI and remove un-necessary functionality    Check it out here:-  https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145/threaded-comments-for-jira?hosting=datacenter&tab=versions   We welcome your feedback and suggestions to further improve the functionality of the app   Regards Peter, votazz Support Team

            Peter Muldoon added a comment -

            There are 130,000 + users of  Threaded Comments for Jira

            The app is available on Cloud & Data Centre 

            Check it out here:-  https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145

            We release a new version every alternate month, and welcome your suggestions

            Peter Muldoon added a comment - There are 130,000 + users of   Threaded Comments for Jira The app is available on Cloud & Data Centre   Check it out here:-   https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145 We release a new version every alternate month, and welcome your suggestions

            Peter Muldoon added a comment -

            Hi  hideyuki.hanai,

            Check out Threaded Comments here:- https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145/threaded-comments-for-jira?hosting=cloud&tab=overview

            Regards,

            Peter, votazz Support Team

            Peter Muldoon added a comment - Hi  hideyuki.hanai , Check out Threaded Comments here:- https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145/threaded-comments-for-jira?hosting=cloud&tab=overview Regards, Peter, votazz Support Team

            hideyuki.hanai added a comment -

            I need threaded comment function.

            I suggest to install as standard function.

            hideyuki.hanai added a comment - I need threaded comment function. I suggest to install as standard function.

            Peter Muldoon added a comment -

             

            Just a quick note to let you know that the latest version 1.47.0 of Threaded Comments 9.11.2                       

            for Data Centre was released today - Monday 30th October 2023

            The release included:

            New Feature - Enabled new title summary field

            New Feature - Enabled administrators to toggle threaded comments by project

            New Feature - Enabled users to pin/unpin a comment

            New Feature - Enabled users to make a comment as a new root comment

            New Feature - Enabled reply to mentions

            Fixed - Comment input box position

            Fixed - CSRF vulnerability at the config TC admin view

            We welcome your feedback and any suggestions to further improve the app

            Check out the new release here:- https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145/threaded-comments-for-jira-threads-replies-nested-comments?hosting=datacenter&tab=overview

            Regards,

            Peter, Votazz Support Team 

            Peter Muldoon added a comment -   Just a quick note to let you know that the latest version 1.47.0 of Threaded Comments 9.11.2                         for Data Centre was released today - Monday 30th October 2023 The release included: New Feature - Enabled new title summary field New Feature - Enabled administrators to toggle threaded comments by project New Feature - Enabled users to pin/unpin a comment New Feature - Enabled users to make a comment as a new root comment New Feature - Enabled reply to mentions Fixed - Comment input box position Fixed - CSRF vulnerability at the config TC admin view We welcome your feedback and any suggestions to further improve the app Check out the new release here:- https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145/threaded-comments-for-jira-threads-replies-nested-comments?hosting=datacenter&tab=overview Regards, Peter, Votazz Support Team 

            Pete @ Threaded Comments for Jira added a comment -

            G'day everyone!

            If you're a Solution Partner with an eye for making things smoother for your clients, lend me your ear for a sec. Here's our two cents on why giving "Threaded Comments for Jira" a gander is worth your while:

            https://community.atlassian.com/t5/App-Central/Should-my-Data-Center-clients-use-Threaded-Comment-for-Jira/td-p/2495544

            Pete @ Threaded Comments for Jira added a comment - G'day everyone! If you're a Solution Partner with an eye for making things smoother for your clients, lend me your ear for a sec. Here's our two cents on why giving "Threaded Comments for Jira" a gander is worth your while: https://community.atlassian.com/t5/App-Central/Should-my-Data-Center-clients-use-Threaded-Comment-for-Jira/td-p/2495544

            Peter Muldoon added a comment -

            Just a quick note to let you know that the latest version 1.46.0 of Threaded Comments 9.11.0 for Data Centre was released today - Tuesday 5th September 2023

            The release included:-

            Compatibility upgrade to Jira 9.11.0

            Enabled - Arabic language translation

            Enabled - Korean language translation of button name to:-  추가하(X)--> 추가(O

            Enabled - Russian language translation of "Write a comment” to:- “Напишите комментарий” 
             
            Fixed - Reply comment box when using Firefox on Ubuntu
             
            Fixed - Input box loading when using Firefox
             
            Fixed - Like/Unlike comment on Jira 8
             
            Fixed - Icon covered by the add comment section
             
            Fixed - Sorting results by “My mentions” and“My comments”  
             
            Check out the new release here:-  ** https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145
            We welcome your feedback and any suggestions to further improve the app

            Regards,

            Peter, votazz Support Team

            Peter Muldoon added a comment - Just a quick note to let you know that the latest version 1.46.0 of Threaded Comments 9.11.0 for Data Centre   was released today - Tuesday 5th September 2023 The release included:- Compatibility upgrade to Jira 9.11.0 Enabled - Arabic language translation Enabled - Korean language translation of button name to:-  추가하(X)--> 추가(O Enabled - Russian language translation of "Write a comment” to:- “Напишите комментарий”    Fixed - Reply comment box when using Firefox on Ubuntu   Fixed - Input box loading when using Firefox   Fixed - Like/Unlike comment on Jira 8   Fixed - Icon covered by the add comment section   Fixed - Sorting results by “My mentions” and“My comments”     Check out the new release here:-  ** https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1212145 We welcome your feedback and any suggestions to further improve the app Regards, Peter, votazz Support Team

              Unassigned Unassigned
              dhardiker Dan Hardiker
              Votes:
              1016 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              408 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated: