• 23
    • 13
    • We collect Confluence feedback from various sources, and we evaluate what we've collected when planning our product roadmap. To understand how this piece of feedback will be reviewed, see our Implementation of New Features Policy.

      NOTE: This suggestion is for Confluence Server. Using Confluence Cloud? See the corresponding suggestion.

      It would be good to allow notifications to include an entire family of pages - so you can opt to watch a page and be notified if it changes, if any of its children change, or if any child page is added or removed.

      Atlassian Status as of November 15, 2018

      Hi all,

      Thanks for all your votes and comments on this suggestion.

      We fully appreciate the value of being able to easily watch a page and it's children with one click, and understand the value this would bring to you.

      This is something we’d ideally like to implement in the future, but it's not currently on our roadmap for the next 12 months. We’re instead focusing on bringing you a new search experience, and are investigating improvements to permissions.

      For more context on this, take a read of the Community blog: A renewed approach to highly voted Server suggestions for Jira and Confluence.

      Alternatively, please take a look at the free Tree View app, available in our Marketplace, which offers this functionality.

      Best,
      Jenny Millman | Product Manager - Confluence Server

            [CONFSERVER-2853] Watch Page and Children

            Harry Knott added a comment -

            OMG - the cloud version just got done. A mere 20 years after the ticket was logged...

             

            Any chance of the server version getting this now?

            Harry Knott added a comment - OMG - the cloud version just got done. A mere 20 years after the ticket was logged...   Any chance of the server version getting this now?

            This is in the top 10 most voted confluence tickets, and been untouched by Atlassian for over 15 years. I wouldn't hold your breath

            This is such a sad reality.

            Cornelius Gillner added a comment - This is in the top 10 most voted confluence tickets, and been untouched by Atlassian for over 15 years. I wouldn't hold your breath This is such a sad reality.

            Atlassian Update – 2nd June 2023

            Hi everyone!

            My name is Charlie and I work in Confluence Data Center.

            We are looking to chat with customers who regularly use Confluence Data Center or Server in a non-admin capacity (creating or reviewing pages and blogs etc.) to meet with us 1:1 for one hour to help inform our upcoming product roadmap.

            We will be running these sessions in June 2023. If any of your team or colleagues are interested in participating, please reach out to confluence-research@atlassian.com.

            Thank you so much for helping us continue to improve and deliver value to the Confluence community!

            Kinds regards,

            Charlie Marriott

            Senior Product Manager
            Confluence Data Center

            Charlie Marriott added a comment - Atlassian Update – 2nd June 2023 Hi everyone! My name is Charlie and I work in Confluence Data Center. We are looking to chat with customers who regularly use Confluence Data Center or Server in a non-admin capacity (creating or reviewing pages and blogs etc.) to meet with us 1:1 for one hour to help inform our upcoming product roadmap. We will be running these sessions in June 2023. If any of your team or colleagues are interested in participating, please reach out to confluence-research@atlassian.com . Thank you so much for helping us continue to improve and deliver value to the Confluence community! Kinds regards, Charlie Marriott Senior Product Manager Confluence Data Center

            Hoping this will happen!

            Juho Kettunen added a comment - Hoping this will happen!

            looking forward to this

            Carmelo Patti added a comment - looking forward to this

            This is in the top 10 most voted confluence tickets, and been untouched by Atlassian for over 15 years.  I wouldn't hold your breath

            Harry Knott added a comment - This is in the top 10 most voted confluence tickets, and been untouched by Atlassian for over 15 years.  I wouldn't hold your breath

            Hi Atlassian, 

            whats the current status of this?

            Will this feature be available on DC?

            Anna Hummel added a comment - Hi Atlassian,  whats the current status of this? Will this feature be available on DC?

            Andra Dinu added a comment -

            Hi Brett, you don't need a ScriptRunner plugin to perform this, all you need is ScriptRunner. 

            In the past, it was the case that this functionality was offered separate in a ScriptRunner plugin, but it has now completely ingested in the core ScriptRunner app.

            Best,

            Andra - ScriptRunner Marketing

             

            Andra Dinu added a comment - Hi Brett, you don't need a ScriptRunner plugin to perform this, all you need is ScriptRunner.  In the past, it was the case that this functionality was offered separate in a ScriptRunner plugin, but it has now completely ingested in the core ScriptRunner app. Best, Andra - ScriptRunner Marketing  

            Voted this up.

            FYI I read in a community discussion that with ScriptRunner you also need a ScriptRunner plugin to perform this. Also, there's a tree-view app that could work but we have not tested any of these options.

            Brett Hall added a comment - Voted this up. FYI I read in  a community discussion  that with ScriptRunner you also need a ScriptRunner plugin to perform this. Also, there's a tree-view app  that could work but we have not tested any of these options.

            Hi All, This can now be achieved using the ScriptRunner for Confluence app (v6.5.0). Users can choose to watch a parent page and all of its descendants and when there are new pages added into that tree, they’ll automatically watch those too. Hope this helps!

            Jillian Patterson added a comment - Hi All, This can now be achieved using the ScriptRunner for Confluence app (v6.5.0). Users can choose to watch a parent page and all of its descendants and when there are new pages added into that tree, they’ll automatically watch those too. Hope this helps!

            What is the current status? The last official information from Atlassian is dated 18 November 2018. It would be great to know if and when this feature will be implemented by Atlassian.
            I know that there is an addon which offers this functionality. But in my opinion such a basic function should be part of the standard product. It makes no sense to blow up your installation with such small addons.

            Deleted Account (Inactive) added a comment - What is the current status? The last official information from Atlassian is dated 18 November 2018. It would be great to know if and when this feature will be implemented by Atlassian. I know that there is an addon which offers this functionality. But in my opinion such a basic function should be part of the standard product. It makes no sense to blow up your installation with such small addons.

            @Andreas Purde, Wow! Thanks for pointing that out. I never even noticed that and wouldn't have seen it without your comment.

            Kathy Kurth added a comment - @Andreas Purde, Wow! Thanks for pointing that out. I never even noticed that and wouldn't have seen it without your comment.

            @Kathy Kurth: your statement is only partly true. Tree View is still free for Server. However you have to use the promotion link provided in the [Marketplace listing|https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1213286/tree-view?hosting=server&tab=overview].

            Andreas Purde added a comment - @Kathy Kurth: your statement is only partly true. Tree View is still free for Server. However you have to use the promotion link provided in the [Marketplace listing| https://marketplace.atlassian.com/apps/1213286/tree-view?hosting=server&tab=overview ].

            Kathy Kurth added a comment - - edited

            @jenny millman - note that the Tree View app you're pointing us to is no longer free.

            Kathy Kurth added a comment - - edited @jenny millman - note that the Tree View app you're pointing us to is no longer free.

            That feature would be very great. I'm working at a big project with plenty of components/stakeholders where I'm only interested in some of them.

            Josef Freundorfer added a comment - That feature would be very great. I'm working at a big project with plenty of components/stakeholders where I'm only interested in some of them.

            Would be great to have that feature as some spaces can be huge thus not completely relevant for one.

            engineering systems added a comment - Would be great to have that feature as some spaces can be huge thus not completely relevant for one.

            Arie, since your question is really not related to this Jira issue the best place to ask that question would be the Atlassian Community.

            Davin Studer added a comment - Arie, since your question is really not related to this Jira issue the best place to ask that question would be the Atlassian Community .

            Hi , is there a way to put the Children Display macrooin a page so that the list of childs pages will display in 2 columns?

            I have a long list and I prefer to have the list split to 2 columns

            Arie Harari added a comment - Hi , is there a way to put the Children Display macrooin a page so that the list of childs pages will display in 2 columns? I have a long list and I prefer to have the list split to 2 columns

            you have my vote as well. Unfortunately, our organization wants to stay current, but relying on 3rd party plugins for functionality that should be native to the tool costs us in terms of added testing and delays before we can provide our users the latest and greatest.

            Please consider making this native to your product.

            Dianne Tessier added a comment - you have my vote as well. Unfortunately, our organization wants to stay current, but relying on 3rd party plugins for functionality that should be native to the tool costs us in terms of added testing and delays before we can provide our users the latest and greatest. Please consider making this native to your product.

            But tree view isn't available for cloud users like me...

            Douglas Lee added a comment - But tree view isn't available for cloud users like me...

            wow, you are right! Works like a charme, now tree view has officially solved the issue. No need for a native integration anymore from my point of view! Tree view now is a must have plugin!

            Tim Mohrbach added a comment - wow, you are right! Works like a charme, now tree view has officially solved the issue. No need for a native integration anymore from my point of view! Tree view now is a must have plugin!

            Tim, I think that Andreas Purde read your comment, because in v 1.3.0 he implemented what you described
            https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/de.edrup.confluence.plugins.tree-view/versions
            It works:

            Kristof Vandermeersch added a comment - Tim, I think that Andreas Purde read your comment, because in v 1.3.0 he implemented what you described https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/de.edrup.confluence.plugins.tree-view/versions It works:

            Tim Mohrbach added a comment - - edited

            The tree view add-on is a crutch. It works, but it's not integrated intuitively, so my users don't know about it unless you show them. A native feature within the usual place of watching a page would be much much better. Until then, I can recommend the tree view.

            Tim Mohrbach added a comment - - edited The tree view add-on is a crutch. It works, but it's not integrated intuitively, so my users don't know about it unless you show them. A native feature within the usual place of watching a page would be much much better. Until then, I can recommend the tree view.

            We're using it, and it's doing the job. So I can recommend it until this feature is integrated.

            Julien Benzimra added a comment - We're using it, and it's doing the job. So I can recommend it until this feature is integrated.

            I agree Leos Leos.

            This free Add-on "Tree View" should do the trick (Watch pagetree):
            https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/de.edrup.confluence.plugins.tree-view/server/overview
            (I haven't tested it yet)
            The reviews are positive.
            Is anyone of you 445 watchers using this "Tree View" Add-on?

            Kristof Vandermeersch added a comment - I agree Leos Leos. This free Add-on "Tree View" should do the trick (Watch pagetree): https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/de.edrup.confluence.plugins.tree-view/server/overview (I haven't tested it yet) The reviews are positive. Is anyone of you 445 watchers using this "Tree View" Add-on?

            Leos Leos added a comment -

            445 watchers are not enough for a feature request

            Leos Leos added a comment - 445 watchers are not enough for a feature request

            +1 for this request...! Really hope to see this sometime soon!

            Tim Mohrbach added a comment - +1 for this request...! Really hope to see this sometime soon!

            Added My Vote.

            Is there any third-party plugin to do this job, as Atlassian is not commenting on this particular feature request?

            R Kaja Mohideen added a comment - Added My Vote. Is there any third-party plugin to do this job, as Atlassian is not commenting on this particular feature request?

            Any update for the community on this feature? The standard Atlassian answer of "We will not implement this as there is comparable feature available from a 3rd party plugin" would be fine.

            Amazes me that more than 10 years have passed and Confluence product managers have not commented on this highly requested feature.

            Ryan Goodwin added a comment - Any update for the community on this feature? The standard Atlassian answer of "We will not implement this as there is comparable feature available from a 3rd party plugin" would be fine. Amazes me that more than 10 years have passed and Confluence product managers have not commented on this highly requested feature.

            I wonder if the creators of that tree view plugin would be willing to donate it to Atlassian so it can be included in the core product, and if Atlassian is willing to accept it. That plugin is exactly what is needed and seems to be very well implemented.

            Elvar Bjarki Böðvarsson added a comment - I wonder if the creators of that tree view plugin would be willing to donate it to Atlassian so it can be included in the core product, and if Atlassian is willing to accept it. That plugin is exactly what is needed and seems to be very well implemented.

            I totally agree that it would be best if Confluence comes with that feature out of the box. For those ones who don't want to wait or don't want to use the commercial (closed source) plugin you may want to try our free open source alternative:

            https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/de.edrup.confluence.plugins.tree-view

            It will remain free and open source.

            Andreas Purde added a comment - I totally agree that it would be best if Confluence comes with that feature out of the box. For those ones who don't want to wait or don't want to use the commercial (closed source) plugin you may want to try our free open source alternative: https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/de.edrup.confluence.plugins.tree-view It will remain free and open source.

            For our purposes, watching a page is far too restrictive - a lot of useful info relating to the topic will go into a child page (often a new page) so won't trigger a notification when watching the page, and with large spaces (which most of ours are), watching the space means that notifications become so numerous they just become spam, so without this feature, the "watch" functionality doesn't meet the requirements.

            Harry Knott added a comment - For our purposes, watching a page is far too restrictive - a lot of useful info relating to the topic will go into a child page (often a new page) so won't trigger a notification when watching the page, and with large spaces (which most of ours are), watching the space means that notifications become so numerous they just become spam, so without this feature, the "watch" functionality doesn't meet the requirements.

            But, an all too-common response ... go get it in the marketplace vs spending maintenance dollars to enhance/fix the core product. Plugins are a solution ... but, they are a maintenance issue as there are always concerns about compatibility, and they add to your upgrade testing effort; plus, several cost money (again, why are we paying maintenance) or soon become paid once they get enough interest and see that they can charge. And, if you are hosted, you often don't get this as an option and many executives don't want to pursue plugins because they are not supported and inject risk.

            Karie Kelly added a comment - But, an all too-common response ... go get it in the marketplace vs spending maintenance dollars to enhance/fix the core product. Plugins are a solution ... but, they are a maintenance issue as there are always concerns about compatibility, and they add to your upgrade testing effort; plus, several cost money (again, why are we paying maintenance) or soon become paid once they get enough interest and see that they can charge. And, if you are hosted, you often don't get this as an option and many executives don't want to pursue plugins because they are not supported and inject risk.

            John Foley added a comment -

            And the commercial Add-On is terrible & costs additional money - double whammy.

            John Foley added a comment - And the commercial Add-On is terrible & costs additional money - double whammy.

            But unfortunately Atlassian isn't interested in this issue of it's customers
            or
            Atlassian has too many advantages from the cooperation with the author of the commercial addon.

            Martin Kukielka added a comment - But unfortunately Atlassian isn't interested in this issue of it's customers or Atlassian has too many advantages from the cooperation with the author of the commercial addon.

            Almost ten years open... and 336 votes makes this the 9th most voted issue in Confluence.

            Jussi Järvinen added a comment - Almost ten years open... and 336 votes makes this the 9th most voted issue in Confluence.

            These would be the options to pass to the CLI. Then just set up windows task scheduler, or a cron job to run the cli every whatever period you want.

            --action addWatch --space "SPACEKEY" --title "PAGENAME" --userId "USERNAME" --descendents

            https://bobswift.atlassian.net/wiki/display/CSOAP/Documentation#Documentation-addWatch

            Davin Studer added a comment - These would be the options to pass to the CLI. Then just set up windows task scheduler, or a cron job to run the cli every whatever period you want. --action addWatch --space "SPACEKEY" --title "PAGENAME" --userId "USERNAME" --descendents https://bobswift.atlassian.net/wiki/display/CSOAP/Documentation#Documentation-addWatch

            Hi Davin Studer, could you show me how to use command line interface to achieve this? Thanks.

            henry henry added a comment - Hi Davin Studer, could you show me how to use command line interface to achieve this? Thanks.

            Bump, and another vote.

            Jim Kennedy added a comment - Bump, and another vote.

            If you want something automatic-ish (not really a word) you could use the Confluence Command Line Interface. You can set up a scheduled task to add watches to a page and its children every hour or so.

            Davin Studer added a comment - If you want something automatic-ish (not really a word) you could use the Confluence Command Line Interface. You can set up a scheduled task to add watches to a page and its children every hour or so.

            I know, Confluence really needs an option to watch all children pages, but at least this might work for some people's use cases.

            Stephen Deutsch added a comment - I know, Confluence really needs an option to watch all children pages, but at least this might work for some people's use cases.

            Tom Miller added a comment -

            This really doesn't solve the problem as new pages are added, they won't be automatically "watched".

            Tom Miller added a comment - This really doesn't solve the problem as new pages are added, they won't be automatically "watched".

            For those customers using OnDemand/Confluence Cloud, you might try using our recently released addon, Bulk Action Tools:

            https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/bulk-action-tools

            It allows you to add/remove page watches from an entire tree of pages, and you can even select the ones you want using checkboxes. You can also use this addon to manage labels and move or delete multiple pages at a time. You can find the documentation here:

            https://streamline.atlassian.net/wiki/display/BAT/Bulk+Action+Tools

            Try it out, and feel free to give feedback.

            Stephen Deutsch added a comment - For those customers using OnDemand/Confluence Cloud, you might try using our recently released addon, Bulk Action Tools: https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/bulk-action-tools It allows you to add/remove page watches from an entire tree of pages, and you can even select the ones you want using checkboxes. You can also use this addon to manage labels and move or delete multiple pages at a time. You can find the documentation here: https://streamline.atlassian.net/wiki/display/BAT/Bulk+Action+Tools Try it out, and feel free to give feedback.

            Another vote!

            Csaba Tamas added a comment - Another vote!

            John Foley added a comment -

            PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE implement this feature request - it would make my life a lot easier! thanks John

            John Foley added a comment - PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE implement this feature request - it would make my life a lot easier! thanks John

            Another vote!

            Stefan Salvisberg added a comment - Another vote!

            Another vote.

            Jim Kennedy added a comment - Another vote.

            Still, this could be a major selling point for Confluence (if it ever gets fixed...).

            Johan van den Hoven added a comment - Still, this could be a major selling point for Confluence (if it ever gets fixed...).

            This issue has been open since 2005, I almost dont expect anything from it anymore.. sadly..

            Freek Bolte added a comment - This issue has been open since 2005, I almost dont expect anything from it anymore.. sadly..

            200ok added a comment -

            @michaelschwarz 4518 is resolved with resolution type "duplicate", ie. this is still the right issue to watch and it's still open/unresolved.

            200ok added a comment - @michaelschwarz 4518 is resolved with resolution type "duplicate", ie. this is still the right issue to watch and it's still open/unresolved.

            If this is duplicated by https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/CONF-4518 (which has status "Resolved" !)
            Why is it's status still "Open" ?

            Deleted Account (Inactive) added a comment - If this is duplicated by https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/CONF-4518 (which has status "Resolved" !) Why is it's status still "Open" ?

            200ok added a comment -

            Nudge This would be awesome.

            200ok added a comment - Nudge This would be awesome.

            Yes, please give us a feedback about the status of this topic!!!
            The commercialization of the adaptavist plugin destroyed our workaround for watching pagetrees.
            Thus this functionality is needed in the standard!

            Martin Kukielka added a comment - Yes, please give us a feedback about the status of this topic!!! The commercialization of the adaptavist plugin destroyed our workaround for watching pagetrees. Thus this functionality is needed in the standard!

            Tolga Sen added a comment -

            Hi, Could you please inform us about its development plan? according to votes this should be planned in near future , right?

            Tolga Sen added a comment - Hi, Could you please inform us about its development plan? according to votes this should be planned in near future , right?

            HI All, Adaptivist commercialized descendant notifications to "Enterprise notifications" - which is now compatible with Confluence up to 5.1.5. See http://www.adaptavist.com/w/products-plugins/premium/enterprise-notifications/

            Matin Schiemann added a comment - HI All, Adaptivist commercialized descendant notifications to "Enterprise notifications" - which is now compatible with Confluence up to 5.1.5. See http://www.adaptavist.com/w/products-plugins/premium/enterprise-notifications/

            We are also using the descendent notification plugin...

            BUT we updated our Confluence and run into http://www.adaptavist.com/display/community/Strange+Email+Subjects+and+Email+Body

            I think we will deacitivate the plugin and have to wait for the core implementation...

            Andre Lehmann added a comment - We are also using the descendent notification plugin... BUT we updated our Confluence and run into http://www.adaptavist.com/display/community/Strange+Email+Subjects+and+Email+Body I think we will deacitivate the plugin and have to wait for the core implementation...

            Jim Birch added a comment -

            Aleš, the Descendant Notification Plugin mentioned above is free and works well for us. It adds a "Watch Page Family" item to the tools menu and allows unwatching. Have a look at it. The plugin is actively maintained by Aptavist.

            Jim Birch added a comment - Aleš, the Descendant Notification Plugin mentioned above is free and works well for us. It adds a "Watch Page Family" item to the tools menu and allows unwatching. Have a look at it. The plugin is actively maintained by Aptavist.

            Hello,
            is that any time plan about that feature?
            Thank you
            Best regards Ales

            Aleš Laňar added a comment - Hello, is that any time plan about that feature? Thank you Best regards Ales

            Jahsie added a comment -

            This features is something we would use. Unfortunately, the descendant Notification Plugin has a bug that basically makes it useless. http://www.adaptavist.com/display/community/Strange+Email+Subjects+and+Email+Body

            Jahsie added a comment - This features is something we would use. Unfortunately, the descendant Notification Plugin has a bug that basically makes it useless. http://www.adaptavist.com/display/community/Strange+Email+Subjects+and+Email+Body

            This feature will be cool. I have many questions about this issue (how to watch family of pages). Please do it this feature.

            Maciej Szwalgin added a comment - This feature will be cool. I have many questions about this issue (how to watch family of pages). Please do it this feature.

            However, as an OnDemand user, the ability to use that plugin is not an option.

            Karie Kelly added a comment - However, as an OnDemand user, the ability to use that plugin is not an option.

            I would suggest the Descendant Notification Plugin - https://plugins.atlassian.com/plugin/details/260

            Christian Buchinger added a comment - I would suggest the Descendant Notification Plugin - https://plugins.atlassian.com/plugin/details/260

            A page was accidentally deleted in confluence. When IT restored it I lost all my watches to that page. The page has about 40+ pages deep. I need to watch those pages again and did not find a way to watch a page with all children.

            Fares Bouchedid added a comment - A page was accidentally deleted in confluence. When IT restored it I lost all my watches to that page. The page has about 40+ pages deep. I need to watch those pages again and did not find a way to watch a page with all children.

            The Plugin can be downloaded here: https://plugins.atlassian.com/plugin/details/260
            It works perfectly in our environment (Confluence 3.1.1).

            Michael Michael added a comment - The Plugin can be downloaded here: https://plugins.atlassian.com/plugin/details/260 It works perfectly in our environment (Confluence 3.1.1).

            This is definitely a MUST-HAVE for all confluence users !!! Please make it true soon. many thanks.

            rainer mueck added a comment - This is definitely a MUST-HAVE for all confluence users !!! Please make it true soon. many thanks.

            Bob Swift added a comment -

            As far as I am concerned, http://confluence.atlassian.com/display/CONFEXT/Descendent+Notification+Plugin satisfies this requirement. And it is not static as mentioned in the comment above.

            Bob Swift added a comment - As far as I am concerned, http://confluence.atlassian.com/display/CONFEXT/Descendent+Notification+Plugin satisfies this requirement. And it is not static as mentioned in the comment above.

            Igor Minar added a comment -

            Hi Audra,

            I believe I evaluated that plugin long time ago. The problem I found is that the notifications are statically assigned when the user signs up for notifications and are not updated when new children are added or old ones are removed (or moved).

            /i

            Igor Minar added a comment - Hi Audra, I believe I evaluated that plugin long time ago. The problem I found is that the notifications are statically assigned when the user signs up for notifications and are not updated when new children are added or old ones are removed (or moved). /i

            AudraA added a comment -

            We agree that this is a good feature request and popular. We want to revamp the notifications part of the product including the watch functionality, which may be a large effort. This is not currently scheduled in the roadmap, but something we will try to improve in the future. The current workaround is to watch the entire space or watch pages individually. I would also like to know if anyone has used the plugin mentioned by Jim above and any comments on it.

            If you're interested to know how we decide on which features to implement, please read this:
            http://confluence.atlassian.com/display/DEV/Implementation+of+New+Features+and+Improvements

            AudraA added a comment - We agree that this is a good feature request and popular. We want to revamp the notifications part of the product including the watch functionality, which may be a large effort. This is not currently scheduled in the roadmap, but something we will try to improve in the future. The current workaround is to watch the entire space or watch pages individually. I would also like to know if anyone has used the plugin mentioned by Jim above and any comments on it. If you're interested to know how we decide on which features to implement, please read this: http://confluence.atlassian.com/display/DEV/Implementation+of+New+Features+and+Improvements

            Jim Birch added a comment -

            A 3rd party plugin to watch a page and decendents was entered in Codegeist. Haven't installed yet bit it looks nice!

            Here's the link: http://confluence.atlassian.com/display/CODEGEIST/Descendent+Notification+Plugin

            Jim Birch added a comment - A 3rd party plugin to watch a page and decendents was entered in Codegeist. Haven't installed yet bit it looks nice! Here's the link: http://confluence.atlassian.com/display/CODEGEIST/Descendent+Notification+Plugin

            Any Update on this feature? I can only echo the comments made by others here.
            We are using Confluence more and more but this is one feature that is delaying many of our potential users migrating content onto wiki.
            Can we expect something in a future release.....?

            Edward Murrison added a comment - Any Update on this feature? I can only echo the comments made by others here. We are using Confluence more and more but this is one feature that is delaying many of our potential users migrating content onto wiki. Can we expect something in a future release.....?

            We're finding that, as we rely upon Confluence more and more, this feature is becoming more important. Due to document size, we have to break documents into smaller chunks.... we now lack the confidence that the correct people are being notified of changes. It's too easy (and painful) to find all the children to try and 'watch' them.

            A feature, like mentioned above... would make things a lot easier.

            Reade Johnson added a comment - We're finding that, as we rely upon Confluence more and more, this feature is becoming more important. Due to document size, we have to break documents into smaller chunks.... we now lack the confidence that the correct people are being notified of changes. It's too easy (and painful) to find all the children to try and 'watch' them. A feature, like mentioned above... would make things a lot easier.

            Just hit a scenario today where this feature would have been perfect. Number of child pages that I wanted to watch in a space that contained top level pages covering related but discrete topics. Watching entire space would provide too many notifications.

            Mark Baker added a comment - Just hit a scenario today where this feature would have been perfect. Number of child pages that I wanted to watch in a space that contained top level pages covering related but discrete topics. Watching entire space would provide too many notifications.

            Jamie added a comment -

            Has this issue made any progress? I can see a need for this in my current work today.

            Jamie added a comment - Has this issue made any progress? I can see a need for this in my current work today.

            Jim Birch added a comment -

            While a sophisticated scheme like James Mortimer proposes might be useful at times, I'd be happy enough with just the addition of a "watch page plus descendants" option. It looks quite straightforward to implement; start with the watch-this-pagers, then climb the tree and add anyone with a "watch descendants" flag then include space watchers.

            Notification on new descendants is a must. What we need is to be able to assign watching briefs for branches of the knowledge base to people so they can stay informed and/or review changes.

            Jim Birch added a comment - While a sophisticated scheme like James Mortimer proposes might be useful at times, I'd be happy enough with just the addition of a "watch page plus descendants" option. It looks quite straightforward to implement; start with the watch-this-pagers, then climb the tree and add anyone with a "watch descendants" flag then include space watchers. Notification on new descendants is a must. What we need is to be able to assign watching briefs for branches of the knowledge base to people so they can stay informed and/or review changes.

            John Price added a comment -

            We had a dev here submit a helpdesk ticket to our Confluence admin asking for this feature. In general we have a lot of requests for better notifications.

            John Price added a comment - We had a dev here submit a helpdesk ticket to our Confluence admin asking for this feature. In general we have a lot of requests for better notifications.

            JamesM added a comment -

            1) We might need to further specify the "DEPTH" of children to watch, or at least (as guy stated but with one addition), cycle or select between:

            • Watch this page
            • Watch this page and it's children (including new ones)
            • Watch this page and it's descedants (including new ones)
            • Watch this space
            • Stop watching

            2) In case it is not obvious, when 'watching a page and all children', you should also by default get a notification for 'new' children created in the sub-heirarchy, plus subsequent edits to that child.

            3) Note: Child pages need to have an 'indicator' to show if they are being watched directly, or indirectly through some page heirarchy watch (much like they currently show if 'space-watch' is in effect.

            4) As per my previous comment, space, page, children, descendants watches should be independantly selectable. For example, I should still be able to turn on/off a page watch for page B, even if it's parent A is already 'watching all children' and the space is being watched. Then if later the space watch or parent A watch are turned off, I'm still watching page B (but not the rest of the space or page heirarchy).

            This could dramatically reduce the number of watches a user has to manage, and is more intuitive to our users that have used other products with 'folder' style notification.

            JamesM added a comment - 1) We might need to further specify the "DEPTH" of children to watch, or at least (as guy stated but with one addition), cycle or select between: Watch this page Watch this page and it's children (including new ones) Watch this page and it's descedants (including new ones) Watch this space Stop watching 2) In case it is not obvious, when 'watching a page and all children', you should also by default get a notification for 'new' children created in the sub-heirarchy, plus subsequent edits to that child. 3) Note: Child pages need to have an 'indicator' to show if they are being watched directly, or indirectly through some page heirarchy watch (much like they currently show if 'space-watch' is in effect. 4) As per my previous comment, space, page, children, descendants watches should be independantly selectable. For example, I should still be able to turn on/off a page watch for page B, even if it's parent A is already 'watching all children' and the space is being watched. Then if later the space watch or parent A watch are turned off, I'm still watching page B (but not the rest of the space or page heirarchy). This could dramatically reduce the number of watches a user has to manage, and is more intuitive to our users that have used other products with 'folder' style notification.

            This is a MUST HAVE feature. Our space currently have more than 1000 pages. By the end of the year we expect this will have double. And this is only the beginning. We must absolutely provide to our moderator a more user friendly way to get notified of new pages for their area of coverage

            valerie husson charlet added a comment - This is a MUST HAVE feature. Our space currently have more than 1000 pages. By the end of the year we expect this will have double. And this is only the beginning. We must absolutely provide to our moderator a more user friendly way to get notified of new pages for their area of coverage

            JamesM added a comment -

            A) This might be greatly facilitated by the new "AncestoryIds" content metadata that has been added to each page once you install the PageTreeSearch plugin (the plugin allows searching of a page and all it's descendents). What before might have been a user interface challenge AND a daunting computational task now may become just a user interface challenge.

            B) rather than cycle, why not an AJAX/Javascript popup window that allows the user to select the watch mode. Also, you should be able to toggle space-wide-watch on and off without affecting your individual page watches, or in the case of this enhancement, individual pagetree watches.

            C) IF RSS feeds use the leucine search, you can set up an RSS feed that uses the ancestorIds field from the pagetreesearch macro to accomplish this goal.

            JamesM added a comment - A) This might be greatly facilitated by the new "AncestoryIds" content metadata that has been added to each page once you install the PageTreeSearch plugin (the plugin allows searching of a page and all it's descendents). What before might have been a user interface challenge AND a daunting computational task now may become just a user interface challenge. B) rather than cycle, why not an AJAX/Javascript popup window that allows the user to select the watch mode. Also, you should be able to toggle space-wide-watch on and off without affecting your individual page watches, or in the case of this enhancement, individual pagetree watches. C) IF RSS feeds use the leucine search, you can set up an RSS feed that uses the ancestorIds field from the pagetreesearch macro to accomplish this goal.

            Absolutely "must have" feature! With a space that consists of 500+ pages it's absolutely necessary.
            It would be greate at least to have some comment from Confluence development. Especially if you look how many people have voted for it.

            Yuri Ziryukin added a comment - Absolutely "must have" feature! With a space that consists of 500+ pages it's absolutely necessary. It would be greate at least to have some comment from Confluence development. Especially if you look how many people have voted for it.

            I agree that the link to watch a space is too obscure and hidden - users tend to miss it unless it's pointed out them.
            The watch children feature is also something my users have asked for

            Ben Coleman added a comment - I agree that the link to watch a space is too obscure and hidden - users tend to miss it unless it's pointed out them. The watch children feature is also something my users have asked for

            With CONF-5114 I asked for a very related feature: to be able to restrict a search to a page and all its children. The key issue here is that as spaces grow they become too large to search and/or watch the entire thing. One suggestion that might be satisfactory is if spaces could be broken up into logical sections that could be watched/searched separately. Two ways to do this are:

            • add the notion of subspaces (CONF-1095 amongst many others).
            • add Guy Fraser's notion of 'space channels' (CONF-5186).

            Andy Armstrong added a comment - With CONF-5114 I asked for a very related feature: to be able to restrict a search to a page and all its children. The key issue here is that as spaces grow they become too large to search and/or watch the entire thing. One suggestion that might be satisfactory is if spaces could be broken up into logical sections that could be watched/searched separately. Two ways to do this are: add the notion of subspaces ( CONF-1095 amongst many others). add Guy Fraser's notion of 'space channels' ( CONF-5186 ).

            Possibly not the most appropriate place to put this, but....

            It would be really nice if a set of options appeared when you click the "watch page" icon:

            • Watch this page
            • Watch this page and it's children
            • Watch this space
            • Stop watching

            You'd basically cycle through these options. The space watching option should be on there as nobody ever thinks to click "Browse Space" then "Advanced" to get to the watch space option so it would be nice if it had some greater visibility.

            Guy Fraser [Adaptavist.com] added a comment - Possibly not the most appropriate place to put this, but.... It would be really nice if a set of options appeared when you click the "watch page" icon: Watch this page Watch this page and it's children Watch this space Stop watching You'd basically cycle through these options. The space watching option should be on there as nobody ever thinks to click "Browse Space" then "Advanced" to get to the watch space option so it would be nice if it had some greater visibility.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              cmiller@atlassian.com Charles Miller (Inactive)
              Votes:
              776 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              359 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated: