Uploaded image for project: 'Jira Service Management Data Center'
  1. Jira Service Management Data Center
  2. JSDSERVER-6586

Previous Approver is added to the Approver History when a back to back approval is set

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Icon: Low Low
    • None
    • 4.1.0
    • Approvals

      Summary

      If we set approval back to back (from status to another status an approval is required), the previous approver will be added even though it is already removed from the approver field.

      Steps to Reproduce

      1. Set the same Approval as in your Workflow setup with 2 Approval Status back to back.
      2. Create a ticket that will use the workflow.
      3. Set only 1 Approver when creating the issue and proceed.
      4. Login as the approver and approve/reject to move it to the next approval status.
      5. After moved, edit the Approver to another user.

      Expected Result

      • The previous approval history will show the previous user while the current approval will be updated with the current user

      Actual Result

      • The current user somehow added to the Approver History of the previous approval status.

      Workaround

      not yet found

        1. 1st status.png
          1st status.png
          127 kB
        2. 1st status after approvedeclined.png
          1st status after approvedeclined.png
          137 kB
        3. after approver replaced.png
          after approver replaced.png
          139 kB

          Form Name

            [JSDSERVER-6586] Previous Approver is added to the Approver History when a back to back approval is set

            This bug is indeed not ideal if you need an accurate approval history recording. We would appreciate, if this could be fixed.

            Thanks!

            Oliver Kurth added a comment - This bug is indeed not ideal if you need an accurate approval history recording. We would appreciate, if this could be fixed. Thanks!

            "We use Jira's approval system for compliance and security approvals. This is a pretty big issue for us, since our operations teams have issues telling when/where things are/were approved. " - This use case is true to us as well. Can we get some support on this? 

            Shivaramakrishnan G added a comment - "We use Jira's approval system for compliance and security approvals. This is a pretty big issue for us, since our operations teams have issues telling when/where things are/were approved. " - This use case is true to us as well. Can we get some support on this? 

            Any movement on this? Looks like it's been pretty stagnant. This is starting to cause more nouse in our company, due to names showing up under different approval status when they shouldn't.

            Jeret Shuck added a comment - Any movement on this? Looks like it's been pretty stagnant. This is starting to cause more nouse in our company, due to names showing up under different approval status when they shouldn't.

            We use Jira's approval system for compliance and security approvals. This is a pretty big issue for us, since our operations teams have issues telling when/where things are/were approved. 

            Would love to see this fixed.

            Jeret Shuck added a comment - We use Jira's approval system for compliance and security approvals. This is a pretty big issue for us, since our operations teams have issues telling when/where things are/were approved.  Would love to see this fixed.

            Any update on this??

            Daniel Lucas added a comment - Any update on this??

            Hi cyilmaz, I've made my previous comment above available to public, please let us know if this does not resolve your issue

            Thanks,

            Lenard

            Lenard Bernardo (Inactive) added a comment - Hi cyilmaz , I've made my previous comment above available to public, please let us know if this does not resolve your issue Thanks, Lenard

            Hi,

            We are using Jira Service Management 4.9.1 and we also have this error. We have been waiting for this problem to be solved for a very long time.
            Can someone make a statement on the subject?

            Regards,

            Cem Yılmaz added a comment - Hi, We are using Jira Service Management 4.9.1 and we also have this error. We have been waiting for this problem to be solved for a very long time. Can someone make a statement on the subject? Regards,

            Hi jrahmadiputra,

            It seems to be related to https://confluence.atlassian.com/adminjiraserver/configuring-jira-service-desk-approvals-938847527.html under `How it works` in the first point:

            You can use the same field for more than one approval step, but we do recommend that if you need more than one approval step on the same workflow, you use different user picker custom fields for each approval step to avoid confusion.

            It could be used as a possible workaround so that the custom field history does not get confused.

            Lenard Bernardo (Inactive) added a comment - - edited Hi jrahmadiputra , It seems to be related to  https://confluence.atlassian.com/adminjiraserver/configuring-jira-service-desk-approvals-938847527.html  under `How it works` in the first point: You can use the same field for more than one approval step, but we do recommend that if you need more than one approval step on the same workflow, you use different user picker custom fields for each approval step to avoid confusion. It could be used as a possible workaround so that the custom field history does not get confused.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              jrahmadiputra Julian (Inactive)
              Affected customers:
              28 This affects my team
              Watchers:
              23 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated: