Details
-
Bug
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Medium
-
2.4.3
-
None
-
Using Crucible+Fisheye v2.4.3, on Linux server with java-1.5.0
Description
Open reviews are moved from the author's "Outbox / Out for Review" to the moderator's "Inbox / To Summarize" when all the reviewers have marked the review as "Completed"
This presents a problem because reviewers may have entered comments and defects that the author has not worked or viewed. Reviewers can still see the review in the Outbox but the author does not see the review.
The author's Outbox needs to include an "Outbox / To Moderator" so they know their review is still active in the system waiting for the Moderator to close the review. This would also permit the author to check their open review to see if they have comments and defects to work.
Another option would be to leave the review in the author's "Outbox / Out for Review" when it is also in the moderator's "Inbox / To Summarize" until the Moderator closes the review.
To replicate the problem:
Open a review with a Moderator and one or more reviewers.
Have each reviewer mark the review as completed.
As the moderator - check the Inbox / To Summarize to see the review
As the author - the review is not visible in their Outbox - their only access is my editing the URL