Uploaded image for project: 'Confluence Cloud'
  1. Confluence Cloud
  2. CONFCLOUD-67129

Link to an undefined page (a page that doesn't exist yet)

    • Our product teams collect and evaluate feedback from a number of different sources. To learn more about how we use customer feedback in the planning process, check out our new feature policy.

      Status Update 16 May 2022

      Seems like this ticket wasn't updated with the latest information. Apologies!

      Adding placeholder links IS supported in the new editor.

      💡 After you add the [new page name]() info to the page, don't forget to press Enter or return on your keyboard to create the link.

      Thank you!
      Traci Wilbanks

      Status Update 13 March 2020

      As we're working through this feature and others, we wanted to address a lot of your concerns as to the future of the new editor and legacy editor.

      Please read our recent community post here: https://community.atlassian.com/t5/Confluence-Cloud-articles/Change-to-your-content-is-in-your-hands/ba-p/1324476

      Thanks,
      Avinoam

       

            [CONFCLOUD-67129] Link to an undefined page (a page that doesn't exist yet)

            See above the ticket...

            [new page name]() 

            will do it, although the created links are forever somehow other than "naturally" linked pages.

            Dirk Spannaus added a comment - See above the ticket... [ new page name]() will do it, although the created links are forever somehow other than "naturally" linked pages.

            lordmacbee added a comment -

            Please reconsider re-implementing this feature. Just consider the time effort here. 

            In the past... type clickety type add '[' typedytype add ']'. Publish, click, edit    2 seconds additional effort to link to a new page. Never mind being able to continue authoring the article/page you are currently working on without losing the flow. 

            Today: typedi type. curse!. Save current page. Create new page. Add title. save. Go back, edit, find link, publish. 

            At least 3 additional steps, probably adds at least 20 seconds to the process. Never mind the frustration every time you consider a link. This is basically taking all the benefits of hyper text out of hyper text. 

            lordmacbee added a comment - Please reconsider re-implementing this feature. Just consider the time effort here.  In the past... type clickety type add ' [' typedytype add '] '. Publish, click, edit    2 seconds additional effort to link to a new page. Never mind being able to continue authoring the article/page you are currently working on without losing the flow.  Today: typedi type. curse!. Save current page. Create new page. Add title. save. Go back, edit, find link, publish.  At least 3 additional steps, probably adds at least 20 seconds to the process. Never mind the frustration every time you consider a link. This is basically taking all the benefits of hyper text out of hyper text. 

            gabriel added a comment -

            this seems like such a core function of creating a wiki

            Write text
            Select text 
            Create link to text to a new page that automatically has the name of the selected text

            DONE

            Now I can keep going on my current page and know that my new blank page is there waiting to remind me to fill it. 

            gabriel added a comment - this seems like such a core function of creating a wiki Write text Select text  Create link to text to a new page that automatically has the name of the selected text DONE Now I can keep going on my current page and know that my new blank page is there waiting to remind me to fill it. 

            Why you can't pick - Undefined Page from the Cmd-K menu is beyond me.... yet again another strange  Atlassian decision.

            Deleted Account (Inactive) added a comment - Why you can't pick - Undefined Page from the Cmd-K menu is beyond me.... yet again another strange  Atlassian decision.

            ewood added a comment - - edited

            Come on @atlassian, we can do better than this! 

            I tried using the work-around and it takes longer to use than the alternative: create a new page, name it and go back to the parent and add the the link to your newly created placeholder page. The work-around also doesn't adopt the link name as the default page title.

            ewood added a comment - - edited Come on @atlassian, we can do better than this!  I tried using the work-around and it takes longer to use than the alternative: create a new page, name it and go back to the parent and add the the link to your newly created placeholder page. The work-around also doesn't adopt the link name as the default page title.

            My guess is the workaround provided at the bottom of the page IS the fix.  Still seems like a "workaround" to me and not a "fix".  I hope there will be a more intuitive built-in "fix" in the future.

            Janet Dixon added a comment - My guess is the workaround provided at the bottom of the page IS the fix.  Still seems like a "workaround" to me and not a "fix".  I hope there will be a more intuitive built-in "fix" in the future.

            Brad Holmes Consultant added a comment - - edited

            Has this feature been abandoned?  Its a shame if so.  It was an essential feature.  The work around just gives me an error.

            Brad Holmes Consultant added a comment - - edited Has this feature been abandoned?  Its a shame if so.  It was an essential feature.  The work around just gives me an error.

            Ole Jørgen added a comment - - edited

            Eh.. is this issue really "Fixed" if the solution is to use the rather cumbersome workaround? Is there an issue tracking fixing it in a user-friendly way?

            EDIT: the workaround doesn't  actually provide the functionality of future-page-link. If I have multiple such "workaround" links, they will NOT automatically link to the page if it's created in the future. (not even the one I clicked..)

            The "workaround" seems to be to link to the create new page?! That does not qualify as a workaround for this feature IMO..

            Ole Jørgen added a comment - - edited Eh.. is this issue really "Fixed" if the solution is to use the rather cumbersome workaround? Is there an issue tracking fixing it in a user-friendly way? EDIT: the workaround doesn't  actually provide the functionality of future-page-link. If I have multiple such "workaround" links, they will NOT automatically link to the page if it's created in the future. (not even the one I clicked..) The "workaround" seems to be to link to the create new page?! That does not qualify as a workaround for this feature IMO..

            Hi Everyone,

            This is Mike from the Confluence team.
            Great news – we have now released links to undefined placeholder pages!

            Here are some documents for reference:

            ME (Inactive) added a comment - Hi Everyone, This is Mike from the Confluence team. Great news – we have now released links to undefined placeholder pages! Here are some documents for reference: Community post:  https://community.atlassian.com/t5/Confluence-articles/Link-to-undefined-placeholder-pages/ba-p/1412785 Support documentation:  https://support.atlassian.com/confluence-cloud/docs/insert-links-and-anchors/#InsertLinksandAnchors-Linktoanundefinedplaceholderpageundefinedpages Our cloud blog  for future updates

            Roel Thys added a comment -

            Just noticed it is finally working in our Confluence instance. So roll-out has indeed started. Hope you all get it soon as well!

            Roel Thys added a comment - Just noticed it is finally working in our Confluence instance. So roll-out has indeed started. Hope you all get it soon as well!

              megan@atlassian.com ME (Inactive)
              vsiqueira Vinicius (Inactive)
              Votes:
              229 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              155 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: