Uploaded image for project: 'Jira Platform Cloud'
  1. Jira Platform Cloud
  2. JRACLOUD-85127

Edit Workflow and Manage Issue Layouts permission doesn't work with JSM company managed projects

    • 257
    • 35
    • Our product teams collect and evaluate feedback from a number of different sources. To learn more about how we use customer feedback in the planning process, check out our new feature policy.

      Issue Summary

      This is reproducible on Data Center: No

      New permission 'Edit Workflow' which has been introduced as part of JRACLOUD-70190 doesn't work with Jira Service Management company-managed project. 

      Same with Manage Issue Layouts permisson as well.

      Updated - Documentation currently mentions these limitations related to JSM project: https://support.atlassian.com/jira-cloud-administration/docs/permissions-for-company-managed-projects/#Administration-Permissions

      Steps to Reproduce

      1. Create a new JSM project (OR use existing one). It must be company-managed project
      2. Make sure Workflow used within the project is NOT shared with another project
      3. Assign project admin role to the user -  (This needed otherwise user will only be able to view the Workflows tab
      4. Assign 'Edit Workflow' and 'Browse Project' permission to the user 
      5. (Optional) Use Permission Helper to verify user has correct permission
      6. Now log in as the user and navigate to Project Settings > Workflow 

      Expected Results

      User should see Edit workflow hyperlink 

      Actual Results

      There is no link for Edit workflow

      Workaround

      Currently there is no known workaround for this behavior. A workaround will be added here when available

            [JRACLOUD-85127] Edit Workflow and Manage Issue Layouts permission doesn't work with JSM company managed projects

            Pinned comments

            Pinned by Alim A.

            Aditi Dalal added a comment -

            Hi all this is a known limitation, as extended project administrator is not yet supported in JSM. Please vote and comment with your use-cases so our team can consider JSM support as part of our future prioritisation for this feature.

            Kind regards,
            Aditi Dalal
            PM, Jira Permissions

            Aditi Dalal added a comment - Hi all this is a known limitation, as extended project administrator is not yet supported in JSM. Please vote and comment with your use-cases so our team can consider JSM support as part of our future prioritisation for this feature. Kind regards, Aditi Dalal PM, Jira Permissions

            All comments

            Sara Rowe added a comment -

            This would be incredibly helpful in our instance, where allowing project admins to edit their own workflows makes logical sense. 

            Sara Rowe added a comment - This would be incredibly helpful in our instance, where allowing project admins to edit their own workflows makes logical sense. 

            We need this as it's very unlogical to disinguish between "normal" and JSM projects. Users at least do not understand it.

            krunoslav.majer added a comment - We need this as it's very unlogical to disinguish between "normal" and JSM projects. Users at least do not understand it.

            Dali added a comment -

            Hi,

            Same problem here, extreme extra work for us Org. admins because of these small adjustments in the workflows that a JSM admin could master in the same way. Unfortunately, this adds up and this feature would be very important.

            Cheers

            Dali added a comment - Hi, Same problem here, extreme extra work for us Org. admins because of these small adjustments in the workflows that a JSM admin could master in the same way. Unfortunately, this adds up and this feature would be very important. Cheers

            Hey guys,
            Our team is really disappointed to see another great feature that was loudly announced with multiple purple, and yellow popups on the JSM project screens to be limited again to Jira Only.
            It's a must-have feature for all big enterprise companies using JSM.
            We are hoping this functionality will be released as soon as possible.

            dkostadinov added a comment - Hey guys, Our team is really disappointed to see another great feature that was loudly announced with multiple purple, and yellow popups on the JSM project screens to be limited again to Jira Only. It's a must-have feature for all big enterprise companies using JSM. We are hoping this functionality will be released as soon as possible.

            Hello, this feature would be really helpful to our team as we are constantly updating workflows. In general, people update workflows need to be able to do it without first reaching out to whoever is managing the JSM 

            Miguel Samayoa added a comment - Hello, this feature would be really helpful to our team as we are constantly updating workflows. In general, people update workflows need to be able to do it without first reaching out to whoever is managing the JSM 

            Joshua Gourgues added a comment - - edited

            This isn't a bug, etc.

            This spotlights a malfunctioning/dysfunctional product offering and is a complete oversight by Atlassian Devs/Management.

            Launching a product without properly assessing "basic permissions needs" seems like a lack of prioritizing efficiency and/or security....

            Hopefully this is remediated quickly.

            Joshua Gourgues added a comment - - edited This isn't a bug, etc. This spotlights a malfunctioning/dysfunctional product offering and is a complete oversight by Atlassian Devs/Management. Launching a product without properly assessing "basic permissions needs" seems like a lack of prioritizing efficiency and/or security.... Hopefully this is remediated quickly.

            Dali added a comment -

            Hi,

            This feature for JSM would be great because the Atlassian admins would be relieved by 70% and the project admins would have fewer dependencies on the Atlassian admins.

            Cheers

            Dali added a comment - Hi, This feature for JSM would be great because the Atlassian admins would be relieved by 70% and the project admins would have fewer dependencies on the Atlassian admins. Cheers

            Adding my vote. Really need a way for competent Project Admins to self serve changes without giving Jira admin.

            Stephen Neil added a comment - Adding my vote. Really need a way for competent Project Admins to self serve changes without giving Jira admin.

            pschaefer added a comment -

            It is a great opportunity for Jira Software and why should it not be part in JSM too?

             

            Agreed to the comments below.

            pschaefer added a comment - It is a great opportunity for Jira Software and why should it not be part in JSM too?   Agreed to the comments below.

            This missing functionality has and will continue to slow down my team's ability to self serve changes we could previously make in the self hosted version of Jira. We now have to stop what we're doing, context switch to filing a request to our IT team, wait until they process the request and take action (spending their time unnecessarily), and then once the request is processed, we can pick back up on the flow we were working on. 

            Not only is this inconvenient and creates additional work for two teams, it is something we could previously self serve in locally hosted Jira and is something we were shown was available in the migration resources.

            I really hope this fix is appropriately prioritized as functionality that customers already expect to exist.

            Emily Sharfstein added a comment - This missing functionality has and will continue to slow down my team's ability to self serve changes we could previously make in the self hosted version of Jira. We now have to stop what we're doing, context switch to filing a request to our IT team, wait until they process the request and take action (spending their time unnecessarily), and then once the request is processed, we can pick back up on the flow we were working on.  Not only is this inconvenient and creates additional work for two teams, it is something we could previously self serve in locally hosted Jira and is something we were shown was available in the migration resources. I really hope this fix is appropriately prioritized as functionality that customers already expect to exist.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              3d70865c1864 Alim A.
              Votes:
              60 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              57 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated: