Uploaded image for project: 'Jira Platform Cloud'
  1. Jira Platform Cloud
  2. JRACLOUD-37873

Allow configuring "ops.bar.group.size.opsbar-transitions" in Jira Cloud

    • 2
    • 37
    • Our product teams collect and evaluate feedback from a number of different sources. To learn more about how we use customer feedback in the planning process, check out our new feature policy.

      Problem Definition

      I have a workflow in Jira where each status has three to four outgoing transitions. JIRA only displays buttons for two transitions, hiding the others inside a "Workflow" dropdown. The choice seems really arbitrary.

      Suggested Solution

      In regular Jira, I could adapt the property ops.bar.group.size.opsbar-transitions (via Advanced settings) to fix this, but I currently cannot make it in the cloud.

      Please consider adding UI for changing this.

      It would also be beneficial if customers could change the Ops Bar Action icons in addition to the workflow transition buttons. I.E. be able to view 'clone' or 'attach files' as a button instead of in the list of it's a heavily used function.

      Why this is important

      The problem is that these transitions are easily overlooked by users not yet used to that workflow . Furthermore, those who do know that there are additional transititions have to make one extra click to trigger them.

      Workaround

      No workaround yet.

            [JRACLOUD-37873] Allow configuring "ops.bar.group.size.opsbar-transitions" in Jira Cloud

            I get that there is a new issue view with only one transition button with a drop-down. That helps so that users see all transitions available. However, the ordering there cannot be influenced by Jira admins, it is just alphabetical within each status category. We would really like to have more flexibility there. For example, from status 'Waiting for support' we would like to offer the transition 'Wait', but this is clearly rather an exception than the standard use case, which is rather 'Start work'. So therefore it is rather cumbersome that the dropdown list starts with the transitions from the status category 'Waiting'. 

             

            Dorothee Rothfuss-Bastian added a comment - - edited I get that there is a new issue view with only one transition button with a drop-down. That helps so that users see all transitions available. However, the ordering there cannot be influenced by Jira admins, it is just alphabetical within each status category. We would really like to have more flexibility there. For example, from status 'Waiting for support' we would like to offer the transition 'Wait', but this is clearly rather an exception than the standard use case, which is rather 'Start work'. So therefore it is rather cumbersome that the dropdown list starts with the transitions from the status category 'Waiting'.   

            Daniel Jimenez added a comment - https://getsupport.atlassian.com/browse/JST-893781

            Does Atlassian take any of these feature improvements seriously? every one of these i see has been open and unresolved for YEARS

            Mark Peterson added a comment - Does Atlassian take any of these feature improvements seriously? every one of these i see has been open and unresolved for YEARS

            John Price added a comment -

            I commented on this last year.  Recently though, we've started to see previews of a new Issue View from agile boards, in which the status transition is just a simple dropdown.  If they are planning on eventually making that the "real" issue view, then this request becomes obsolete.  I like the new view much better overall.  They just need to refine it a little bit.

            John Price added a comment - I commented on this last year.  Recently though, we've started to see previews of a new Issue View from agile boards, in which the status transition is just a simple dropdown.  If they are planning on eventually making that the "real" issue view, then this request becomes obsolete.  I like the new view much better overall.  They just need to refine it a little bit.

            This has become a problem for us with not having control of how many buttons show.  It is a little weird that you have to click the drop down to see additional work-flows and it is not very intuitive.   I would love to have control over how many additional buttons can show.

            Joshua Polsky added a comment - This has become a problem for us with not having control of how many buttons show.  It is a little weird that you have to click the drop down to see additional work-flows and it is not very intuitive.   I would love to have control over how many additional buttons can show.

            John Price added a comment -

            This affects our cloud installation which has many teams (50+) with various workflows.  We know how to control the order in which the transitions appear, but can't set the # of buttons like we could in JIRA Server.  In general I think having some of the items top-level and others in a drop-down is mixing UI paradigms.  

            John Price added a comment - This affects our cloud installation which has many teams (50+) with various workflows.  We know how to control the order in which the transitions appear, but can't set the # of buttons like we could in JIRA Server.  In general I think having some of the items top-level and others in a drop-down is mixing UI paradigms.  

            How embarrassing, Atlassian. You have someone selling bug fixes...

            Mat Chavez added a comment - How embarrassing, Atlassian. You have someone selling bug fixes...

            We have added support for this using our new add-on in tandem with a browser extension. Check it out at https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/bandage-jira/cloud/overview

            Boris Berenberg - Atlas Authority added a comment - We have added support for this using our new add-on in tandem with a browser extension. Check it out at https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/bandage-jira/cloud/overview

            Mat Chavez added a comment -

            Also, upvote Becky... should be responsive.

            Mat Chavez added a comment - Also, upvote Becky... should be responsive.

            Mat Chavez added a comment -

            This should be much, much simpler... transition properties should have a 5th tab: Triggers, Conditions, Validators, Post Functions, and Actions Order. The new tab would show the number of buttons, defaulting to 2. The order would be sorted through a simple visual AJAX sorter which would set the opsbar.sequence values for each transition.

            This should not be a property that users have to assign a value using the List. It's HIGHLY confusing because you cannot set the opsbar.sequence using the Diagram. The inability to use the Diagram View for opsbar.sequence is not documented anywhere. It's just assumed that users would understand, even though it's exactly the same when you get the general properties of the transition.

            Mat Chavez added a comment - This should be much, much simpler... transition properties should have a 5th tab: Triggers, Conditions, Validators, Post Functions, and Actions Order. The new tab would show the number of buttons, defaulting to 2. The order would be sorted through a simple visual AJAX sorter which would set the opsbar.sequence values for each transition. This should not be a property that users have to assign a value using the List. It's HIGHLY confusing because you cannot set the opsbar.sequence using the Diagram. The inability to use the Diagram View for opsbar.sequence is not documented anywhere. It's just assumed that users would understand, even though it's exactly the same when you get the general properties of the transition.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              jensbannmann Jens Bannmann
              Votes:
              55 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              51 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated: