• 169
    • 2
    • Our product teams collect and evaluate feedback from a number of different sources. To learn more about how we use customer feedback in the planning process, check out our new feature policy.

      NOTE: This suggestion is for Confluence Cloud. Using Confluence Server? See the corresponding suggestion.

      Problem Definition

      Administrators can't see the list of spaces where each user has access.

      Suggested Solution

      Implement a solution similar to View Project Roles for User on JIRA so administrators can see the users' spaces.

      Workaround

      For Confluence Server:

            [CONFCLOUD-42853] List which spaces a user can access

            Pinned comments

            Hi everyone - I want to share that we've released a new feature, User Access, where admins can download a CSV that contains the spaces that a selected user or group has access to. As a result, we're closing this ticket.

            Here is a link to the Community post about the feature with additional details:

            https://community.atlassian.com/t5/Confluence-Cloud-Admins-articles/Introducing-User-Access-Where-admins-can-audit-troubleshoot/ba-p/2836977

            John Hooper added a comment - Hi everyone - I want to share that we've released a new feature, User Access, where admins can download a CSV that contains the spaces that a selected user or group has access to. As a result, we're closing this ticket. Here is a link to the Community post about the feature with additional details: https://community.atlassian.com/t5/Confluence-Cloud-Admins-articles/Introducing-User-Access-Where-admins-can-audit-troubleshoot/ba-p/2836977

            All comments

            I also hope, they add this feature to Confluence, it's weird that Jira has that feature but not Confluence.

            I would also ask the same feature for groups, so you can see which group has access to which space.

            That Workaround, is completly useless, if you work in a company, where the Database is managed in the Database-Team, and the Application in the Application-Team...

            I have to always call our database-team, if i want to look up which person or group has access to which space...

            Mikail Arda added a comment - I also hope, they add this feature to Confluence, it's weird that Jira has that feature but not Confluence. I would also ask the same feature for groups, so you can see which group has access to which space. That Workaround, is completly useless, if you work in a company, where the Database is managed in the Database-Team, and the Application in the Application-Team... I have to always call our database-team, if i want to look up which person or group has access to which space...

            Matt added a comment -

            Completely agree with 04bd8936a9c8, this csv is a mess!

            Matt added a comment - Completely agree with 04bd8936a9c8 , this csv is a mess!

            Tim Ely added a comment -

            I just downloaded the csv for a user, and this is a complete mess. I don't see how this is going to help at all. Please open this ticket back up and keep refining it until it is easy enough for anybody to understand.

            Tim Ely added a comment - I just downloaded the csv for a user, and this is a complete mess. I don't see how this is going to help at all. Please open this ticket back up and keep refining it until it is easy enough for anybody to understand.

            Agree with 3b21f807ea4a . Do you have no UX designers at Atlassian? That is a poor implementation of the initial feature request.

            Nathan Bradtke added a comment - Agree with 3b21f807ea4a . Do you have no UX designers at Atlassian? That is a poor implementation of the initial feature request.

            62c32a53ff47 The User Access feature is a nice start, but it's not really good enough.

            Seeing what Spaces a select user or group has access to should be a quick an snappy job, not something that requires downloading a CSV, opening Excel (or whatever), and manipulating the file there. That's just too clunky

            In Jira there is the _https://MYSITE.atlassian.net/secure/admin/roles/ViewUserProjectRoles.jspa?accountId=_ page that'll show you every Project a User has access to.
            You still have to dig out the users ID, but it's a lot better than downloading and faffing about with a CSV.

            Rune Rasmussen added a comment - 62c32a53ff47 The User Access feature is a nice start, but it's not really good enough. Seeing what Spaces a select user or group has access to should be a quick an snappy job, not something that requires downloading a CSV, opening Excel (or whatever), and manipulating the file there. That's just too clunky In Jira there is the _ https://MYSITE.atlassian.net/secure/admin/roles/ViewUserProjectRoles.jspa?accountId=_ page that'll show you every Project a User has access to. You still have to dig out the users ID, but it's a lot better than downloading and faffing about with a CSV.

            Hi everyone - I want to share that we've released a new feature, User Access, where admins can download a CSV that contains the spaces that a selected user or group has access to. As a result, we're closing this ticket.

            Here is a link to the Community post about the feature with additional details:

            https://community.atlassian.com/t5/Confluence-Cloud-Admins-articles/Introducing-User-Access-Where-admins-can-audit-troubleshoot/ba-p/2836977

            John Hooper added a comment - Hi everyone - I want to share that we've released a new feature, User Access, where admins can download a CSV that contains the spaces that a selected user or group has access to. As a result, we're closing this ticket. Here is a link to the Community post about the feature with additional details: https://community.atlassian.com/t5/Confluence-Cloud-Admins-articles/Introducing-User-Access-Where-admins-can-audit-troubleshoot/ba-p/2836977

            Lawrence Matthew added a comment - - edited

            ee1911a8f30a , psilveira 
            This is a basic requirement for tool admins and maintainers. 

            Lawrence Matthew added a comment - - edited ee1911a8f30a , psilveira   This is a basic requirement for tool admins and maintainers. 

            This should definitly be by default!

            Marcio Cordeiro added a comment - This should definitly be by default!

            Confluence admins would love Atlassian way more if you deliver this feature!

            Oresta Tymchyshyn added a comment - Confluence admins would love Atlassian way more if you deliver this feature!

            How is this not a feature at launch, expecting users to find workaround is ridiculous.

            Russell Davis added a comment - How is this not a feature at launch, expecting users to find workaround is ridiculous.

            Come on, Atlassian.  It is really quite annoying to run APIs when this system should have had this available to admins on launch.

            Jabin Burkhart added a comment - Come on, Atlassian.  It is really quite annoying to run APIs when this system should have had this available to admins on launch.

            Same as 3b21f807ea4a we migrated from server to cloud and then synced with our AD. We now want to start cleaning up groups but we don't know which groups have access to what spaces/pages.

            Jonathan Bohlmann added a comment - Same as 3b21f807ea4a we migrated from server to cloud and then synced with our AD. We now want to start cleaning up groups but we don't know which groups have access to what spaces/pages.

            Copying access, reviewing access, removing access. All tasks that would be made easier if this feature existed.

            We're clearing out some old groups from our pre-user provisioning days, and need to verify that we don't break some legacy permissions for a few select system accounts.
            We have more than 2.000 spaces.

            Having this feature would really make our admin lives a lot easier.

            Instead now we have to iterate though all spaces with the REST API to get the Space IDs, then use those to iterate through and get permissions for all spaces, so we can make sure we aren't breaking anything.

            Also, given how this suggestion is 8 years old, it's not so much "gathering interest" as much as it's just gathering dust...

            Rune Rasmussen added a comment - Copying access, reviewing access, removing access. All tasks that would be made easier if this feature existed. We're clearing out some old groups from our pre-user provisioning days, and need to verify that we don't break some legacy permissions for a few select system accounts. We have more than 2.000 spaces. Having this feature would really make our admin lives a lot easier. Instead now we have to iterate though all spaces with the REST API to get the Space IDs, then use those to iterate through and get permissions for all spaces, so we can make sure we aren't breaking anything. Also, given how this suggestion is 8 years old, it's not so much "gathering interest" as much as it's just gathering dust...

            Dusty added a comment -

            This is truly unfortunate that this is not a feature to this day still. It makes it incredibly difficult to copy permissions from contractors and other users that don't fall under the default global permissions. This should be a default feature.

            Dusty added a comment - This is truly unfortunate that this is not a feature to this day still. It makes it incredibly difficult to copy permissions from contractors and other users that don't fall under the default global permissions. This should be a default feature.

            Hi! Tech added a comment -

            This should totally be a default!

            Hi! Tech added a comment - This should totally be a default!

            We need this feature on confluence cloud !

            Luc Grangier added a comment - We need this feature on confluence cloud !

            We need this feature on Confluence Cloud, would make Admins work a little bit lighter!

            Alejandra Escalante added a comment - We need this feature on Confluence Cloud, would make Admins work a little bit lighter!

            We need this feature.

            Nathan Bradtke added a comment - We need this feature.

            Seems like a good feature to have. For it.

            John Sandy (RP) added a comment - Seems like a good feature to have. For it.

            Really really need this. Thanks very much. 

            Jamie

            Jamie Gordon added a comment - Really really need this. Thanks very much.  Jamie

            Not having this in the Cloud version makes it unnecessarily cumbersome to do an access review.

            You can easily find queries to run against a Server/Data Center Confluence to get this information,
            so presumably this shouldn't be too much work? (easy for me to say, I know)

            Thomas Brenna added a comment - Not having this in the Cloud version makes it unnecessarily cumbersome to do an access review. You can easily find queries to run against a Server/Data Center Confluence to get this information, so presumably this shouldn't be too much work? (easy for me to say, I know)

            We really would like to see who can access which space from a broad view and which spaces they have accessed.

            Ben Van Walbeek added a comment - We really would like to see who can access which space from a broad view and which spaces they have accessed.

            This would be a very useful feature for administrators

            Arnar Símonarson added a comment - This would be a very useful feature for administrators

            Charneet Sodhi (Inactive) added a comment - https://getsupport.atlassian.com/browse/JST-909115

            I can not believe this feature does not exist.

            Anton LYTVYNOV added a comment - I can not believe this feature does not exist.

            We need this feature on confluence cloud !

            Emerick Morand added a comment - We need this feature on confluence cloud !

            This data should also be available using OAuth via the GraphQL api.

            Varell Hawkins added a comment - This data should also be available using OAuth via the GraphQL api.

            I also think this should have been an out-of-the-box feature which needs to be implemented as soon as possible.

            Gaining an insight into who can see which data is essential, as there might be very sensitive data in some spaces. I think we need something like the Permission Helper in Jira, which is invaluable to determine which users can and cannot access Jira Projects, boards or issues.

            The way it works right now is way to complex and cumbersome, two words I do not like to hear when dealing with access to sensitive data.

            Deleted Account (Inactive) added a comment - I also think this should have been an out-of-the-box feature which needs to be implemented as soon as possible. Gaining an insight into who can see which data is essential, as there might be very sensitive data in some spaces. I think we need something like the Permission Helper in Jira, which is invaluable to determine which users can and cannot access Jira Projects, boards or issues. The way it works right now is way to complex and cumbersome, two words I do not like to hear when dealing with access to sensitive data.

            Mia Bright added a comment -

            I need to be able to see which spaces a group or person has access to for administration purposes. We have a large list of groups and many are redundant but we cannot see where they have access before removing them.

            Mia Bright added a comment - I need to be able to see which spaces a group or person has access to for administration purposes. We have a large list of groups and many are redundant but we cannot see where they have access before removing them.

            Tim Ely added a comment -

            This should be an out of the box feature.  Please get this done.

            Tim Ely added a comment - This should be an out of the box feature.  Please get this done.

            Also requesting this as a new Admin on our Confluence site.  We get a fair amount of requests from people that are replacing former employees asking for the same access as their predecessor.  While we're slowly moving to more group use, the old Admin had many spaces not set up with group permissions. so it's a slow and painful process.

            Glenn Piper added a comment - Also requesting this as a new Admin on our Confluence site.  We get a fair amount of requests from people that are replacing former employees asking for the same access as their predecessor.  While we're slowly moving to more group use, the old Admin had many spaces not set up with group permissions. so it's a slow and painful process.

            Adding my voice here. As a new employee being onboarded, I will be administering some, but not all of the spaces within our Cloud Instance. The spaces match that of an existing employee, but as I understand it, we have no way of pulling that list. Let's make some sort of list, or query, or something, pretty please.

            Bert Jansmann added a comment - Adding my voice here. As a new employee being onboarded, I will be administering some, but not all of the spaces within our Cloud Instance. The spaces match that of an existing employee, but as I understand it, we have no way of pulling that list. Let's make some sort of list, or query, or something, pretty please.

            Joe Lima added a comment -

            Yes, please this functionality is a must have to all Confluence Administrators.    As an additional feature, it would be great to also mirror another user's account but I know, I might be asking too much.   

            Joe Lima added a comment - Yes, please this functionality is a must have to all Confluence Administrators.    As an additional feature, it would be great to also mirror another user's account but I know, I might be asking too much.    

            It would be VERY handy to have a macro or other mechanism that list out all the confluence space for which a group or user had access.
            The ability to visually confirm tracking our "Contractors" group access would be a tremendous 'security verification' asset!

            Charles Johnson added a comment - It would be VERY handy to have a macro or other mechanism that list out all the confluence space for which a group or user had access. The ability to visually confirm tracking our "Contractors" group access would be a tremendous 'security verification' asset!

            The given workaround does not work in postgre database.

            ProekspertBit added a comment - The given workaround does not work in postgre database.

              ee1911a8f30a Marie Casabonne
              psilveira Paula Silveira
              Votes:
              421 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              169 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: