Uploaded image for project: 'Confluence Server and Data Center'
  1. Confluence Server and Data Center
  2. CONFSERVER-5095

Page edit permissions should be inherited by pages, like view permissions are

    XMLWordPrintable

    Details

    • UIS:
      927
    • Support reference count:
      64
    • Feedback Policy:
      We collect Confluence feedback from various sources, and we evaluate what we've collected when planning our product roadmap. To understand how this piece of feedback will be reviewed, see our Implementation of New Features Policy.

      Description

      NOTE: This suggestion is for Confluence Server. Using Confluence Cloud? See the corresponding suggestion.

      Edit restrictions are not inherited.
      When we have a big existing space and we want to change edit permissions of a hierarchy, it's very painfull because we have to change manually the permissions of every pages of this hierarchy.
      We should be able to optionally inherit 'edit' permissions so as to 'view' permissions does.

      In fact, I don't really understand why you do it for 'view' permissions and not for 'edit' permissions.

       

      Atlassian Update, June 2020

      Hi everyone

      First of all, apologies for the time between updates and thank you for the ideas and feedback you have provided in these comments. It’s always helpful to understand how you work and how we can improve Confluence to better facilitate that. We have decided to close this issue as we won’t be addressing it in the foreseeable future. I wanted to take the opportunity to explain why.

      Atlassian’s products are founded on encouraging open ways of working for all of our customers, and that influences many of the decisions we make about individual product features. Depending on the way that your teams work, you may find that this “open” model does not suit and we have seen that reflected in several feature requests.

      This request has been open for nearly as long as Confluence has existed, and has been looked at by many Atlassians over the years. More recently, we planned and explored ways to resolve this and other permission-related challenges through research and design work. We took these opportunities to speak with a number of customers to validate use cases and ideas.

      That brought us to a series of conclusions. Information often has a specific audience, and Confluence provides granular permissions controls, so that the right people can see the right content. This can get complicated, as it may include modifications to site and space level permissions, and/or page level restrictions that can be applied at a parent or child page level.

      Changing Confluence’s model to offer edit permissions inheritance (in the same way view permissions are inherited) wasn’t the right way to address these needs:

      • Some customers rely on the way restrictions currently exist to lock down top-level pages and allow child pages to be open; we didn’t want to adversely affect those that need to have Confluence work this way.
      • Providing an option and explaining the ramifications of view/edit restriction decisions in a single dialog box is challenging, particularly when permissions are also in play. Over the last year we have made material progress on improving transparency of permissions, but that also served to demonstrate the complexity of messaging needed for possible different scenarios.
      • Through multiple rounds of design and customer feedback, there wasn’t a solution that passed our high quality bar for setting restrictions that allowed users to quickly and easily make decisions and understand the impact of them.

      That said, we have considered multiple other approaches. Each of these has had significant development estimates, and these types of changes are continually prioritised against other improvements on the basis of which would provide more value to more customers.

      As a result of this process, in Confluence Server and Data Center 7.3 we released a number of key features which addressed multiple other permission issues and requests which affect a large proportion of our customers; making it clearer who is able to view a page (Confluence Server and Data Center) and enabling admins to troubleshoot permission issues (Confluence Data Center). I know that you may find this disappointing and small consolation, given we’ve not met your specific request.

      In the interests of being open, I wanted to provide this lengthier update and give you some clarity on this issue. Please know that we do read and listen to your feedback, even if we are not able to address the comments on issues. This is one of many channels that we have and take into consideration when determining our roadmap and we always appreciate your feedback.

      Thanks

      Makisa | Senior Product Manager, Confluence Server and Data Center

        Attachments

          Issue Links

            Activity

              People

              Assignee:
              Unassigned
              Reporter:
              rickye Richard THIBAULT
              Votes:
              939 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              536 Start watching this issue

                Dates

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: