It is very difficult when looking at a pull request to figure out what comments you have read. You can look at the activity stream to get some idea, but if the comment is a response to a previous comment, you basically have to scroll through the entire activity log which can be quite long.

We often have pull requests that have 20 or more comments. At this point, it become difficult to keep track of.

I noticed there is now a count of comments for a pull request. It would be nice if there was a similar count of unread comments and some additional indication of unread comments on maybe the diff tab on a per file basis. This functionality is available in Crucible and our team members are used to having this feature. Not having it in Stash makes it difficult to use and some members are at the point they rather use Crucible for reviews.

This feature could probably also be expanded to non-pull request comments too (i.e., commit comments).

Thanks,
Dave Humeniuk