• Type: Bug
• Resolution: Unresolved
• Priority: Low (View bug fix roadmap)
• Fix Version/s: None
• Affects Version/s: 8.20.10
• Component/s: DVCS Connector
• Labels:

  • ril

1. 

   direct-comment.png

   595 kB

   27/Jul/2023 6:16 AM

2. 

   left-a-comment.png

   962 kB

   27/Jul/2023 6:16 AM

[JSWSERVER-21860] Adding comment from review changes page in GitHub doesn't reflect in Jira development panel

Marc Dacanay made changes - 16/Oct/2024 4:17 AM

Labels

New: ril

Marc Dacanay made changes - 16/Oct/2024 4:17 AM

Remote Link

New: This issue links to "Internal ticket (Web Link)" [ 956806 ]

SET Analytics Bot made changes - 20/Feb/2024 3:02 AM

UIS

Original: 1

New: 0

SET Analytics Bot made changes - 18/Feb/2024 2:20 AM

UIS

New: 1

SET Analytics Bot made changes - 28/Jul/2023 4:03 AM

Support reference count

New: 1

Anupam Singh Deo (Inactive) made changes - 27/Jul/2023 10:36 AM

Description

Original: h3. Issue Summary Gitlab comments from review changes page doesn't reflect in Jira development panel This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes) / (no) h3. Steps to Reproduce * Have Jira set up with GitHub Enterprise * Create a commit and pull request mapping with a Jira issue * In the PR, add direct comments (example: add 4 comments). These are the comments that will be of the format *{{_username_ commented}}* !direct-comment.png|thumbnail! * Open the PR link in a separate page, add 2 comments from Submit review page. These will be in the format *{{(_username_ left a comment)}}* !left-a-comment.png|thumbnail! h3. Expected Results * Jira should display total of 6 messages (4 directly added and 2 from the Submit review/review changes page) h3. Actual Results * Jira displays the comment count to 4 and doesn't account for the two comments which are not directly added in the page (of the format *{{(username left a comment)}}*) * The reviewer column is also inconsistent. If a comment was added with the format (*_username_ left a comment*), then the reviewers information will not be seen In this screenshot, the count of comments only displays the directly added comments. h3. Workaround * Add the comments directly

New: h3. Issue Summary Gitlab comments from review changes page doesn't reflect in Jira development panel This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes) / (no) h3. Steps to Reproduce * Have Jira set up with GitHub Enterprise * Create a commit and pull request mapping with a Jira issue * In the PR, add direct comments (example: add 4 comments). These are the comments that will be of the format *{{_username_ commented}}* !direct-comment.png|thumbnail! * Open the PR link in a separate page, add 2 comments from Submit review page. These will be in the format *{{(_username_ left a comment)}}* !left-a-comment.png|thumbnail! h3. Expected Results * Jira should display total of 6 messages (4 directly added and 2 from the Submit review/review changes page) h3. Actual Results * Jira displays the comment count to 4 and doesn't account for the two comments which are not directly added in the page (of the format *{{(username left a comment)}}*) * The reviewer column is also inconsistent. If a comment was added with the format (*_username_ left a comment*), then the reviewers information will not be seen h3. Workaround * Add the comments directly

Anupam Singh Deo (Inactive) made changes - 27/Jul/2023 10:36 AM

Description

Original: h3. Issue Summary Gitlab comments from review changes page doesn't reflect in Jira development panel This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes) / (no) h3. Steps to Reproduce * Have Jira set up with GitHub Enterprise * Create a commit and pull request mapping with a Jira issue * In the PR, add direct comments (example: add 4 comments). These are the comments that will be of the format *{{username commented}}* !direct-comment.png|thumbnail! * Open the PR link in a separate page, add 2 comments from Submit review page. These will be in the format *{{(username left a comment)}}* !left-a-comment.png|thumbnail! h3. Expected Results * Jira should display total of 6 messages (4 directly added and 2 from the Submit review/review changes page) h3. Actual Results * Jira displays the comment count to 4 and doesn't account for the two comments which are not directly added in the page (of the format *{{(username left a comment)}}*) * The reviewer column is also inconsistent. If a comment was added with the format (username left a comment), then the reviewers information will not be seen In this screenshot, the count of comments only displays the directly added comments. h3. Workaround * Add the comments directly

New: h3. Issue Summary Gitlab comments from review changes page doesn't reflect in Jira development panel This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes) / (no) h3. Steps to Reproduce * Have Jira set up with GitHub Enterprise * Create a commit and pull request mapping with a Jira issue * In the PR, add direct comments (example: add 4 comments). These are the comments that will be of the format *{{_username_ commented}}* !direct-comment.png|thumbnail! * Open the PR link in a separate page, add 2 comments from Submit review page. These will be in the format *{{(_username_ left a comment)}}* !left-a-comment.png|thumbnail! h3. Expected Results * Jira should display total of 6 messages (4 directly added and 2 from the Submit review/review changes page) h3. Actual Results * Jira displays the comment count to 4 and doesn't account for the two comments which are not directly added in the page (of the format *{{(username left a comment)}}*) * The reviewer column is also inconsistent. If a comment was added with the format (*_username_ left a comment*), then the reviewers information will not be seen In this screenshot, the count of comments only displays the directly added comments. h3. Workaround * Add the comments directly

Anupam Singh Deo (Inactive) made changes - 27/Jul/2023 10:35 AM

Description

Original: h3. Issue Summary Gitlab comments from review changes page doesn't reflect in Jira development panel This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes) / (no) h3. Steps to Reproduce * Have Jira set up with GitHub Enterprise * Create a commit and pull request mapping with a Jira issue * In the PR, add direct comments (example: add 4 comments). These are the comments that will be of the format *{{username commented}}* !direct-comment.png|thumbnail! * Open the PR link in a separate page, add 2 comments from Submit review page. These will be in the format *{{(username left a comment)}}* !left-a-comment.png|thumbnail! h3. Expected Results * Jira should display total of 6 messages (4 directly added and 2 from the Submit review/review changes page) h3. Actual Results * Jira displays the comment count to 4 and doesn't account for the two comments which are not directly added in the page (of the format *{{(username left a comment)}}*) * The reviewer column is also inconsistent and we couldn't ascertain when the icons for reviewers appear and when they don't. In this screenshot, the count of comments only displays the directly added comments. h3. Workaround * Add the comments directly

New: h3. Issue Summary Gitlab comments from review changes page doesn't reflect in Jira development panel This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes) / (no) h3. Steps to Reproduce * Have Jira set up with GitHub Enterprise * Create a commit and pull request mapping with a Jira issue * In the PR, add direct comments (example: add 4 comments). These are the comments that will be of the format *{{username commented}}* !direct-comment.png|thumbnail! * Open the PR link in a separate page, add 2 comments from Submit review page. These will be in the format *{{(username left a comment)}}* !left-a-comment.png|thumbnail! h3. Expected Results * Jira should display total of 6 messages (4 directly added and 2 from the Submit review/review changes page) h3. Actual Results * Jira displays the comment count to 4 and doesn't account for the two comments which are not directly added in the page (of the format *{{(username left a comment)}}*) * The reviewer column is also inconsistent. If a comment was added with the format (username left a comment), then the reviewers information will not be seen In this screenshot, the count of comments only displays the directly added comments. h3. Workaround * Add the comments directly

Anupam Singh Deo (Inactive) made changes - 27/Jul/2023 10:35 AM

Description

Original: h3. Issue Summary Gitlab comments from review changes page doesn't reflect in Jira development panel This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes) / (no) h3. Steps to Reproduce * Have Jira set up with GitHub Enterprise * Create a commit and pull request mapping with a Jira issue * In the PR, add direct comments (example: add 4 comments). These are the comments that will be of the format *{{username commented}}* !direct-comment.png|thumbnail! * Open the PR link in a separate page, add 2 comments from Submit review page. These will be in the format *{{(username left a comment)}}* !left-a-comment.png|thumbnail! h3. Expected Results * Jira should display total of 6 messages (4 directly added and 2 from the Submit review/review changes page)  !sample-display-jira.png|thumbnail! h3. Actual Results * Jira displays the comment count to 4 and doesn't account for the two comments which are not directly added in the page (of the format *{{(username left a comment)}}*) * The reviewer column is also inconsitent and we couldn't ascertain when the icons for reviewers appear and when they don't. In this screenshot, the count of comments only displays the directly added comments. h3. Workaround * Add the comments directly

New: h3. Issue Summary Gitlab comments from review changes page doesn't reflect in Jira development panel This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes) / (no) h3. Steps to Reproduce * Have Jira set up with GitHub Enterprise * Create a commit and pull request mapping with a Jira issue * In the PR, add direct comments (example: add 4 comments). These are the comments that will be of the format *{{username commented}}* !direct-comment.png|thumbnail! * Open the PR link in a separate page, add 2 comments from Submit review page. These will be in the format *{{(username left a comment)}}* !left-a-comment.png|thumbnail! h3. Expected Results * Jira should display total of 6 messages (4 directly added and 2 from the Submit review/review changes page) h3. Actual Results * Jira displays the comment count to 4 and doesn't account for the two comments which are not directly added in the page (of the format *{{(username left a comment)}}*) * The reviewer column is also inconsistent and we couldn't ascertain when the icons for reviewers appear and when they don't. In this screenshot, the count of comments only displays the directly added comments. h3. Workaround * Add the comments directly

Anupam Singh Deo (Inactive) made changes - 27/Jul/2023 10:35 AM

Attachment

Original: sample-display-jira.png [ 441466 ]

Load more older events