Uploaded image for project: 'Compass'
  1. Compass
  2. COMPASS-112

Support for defining scorecard passing criteria at the component level.

    • 1
    • Our product teams collect and evaluate feedback from a number of different sources. To learn more about how we use customer feedback in the planning process, check out our new feature policy.

      We would like the ability to configure passing thresholds for DORA metric scorecards on a per-component basis. While the global configuration should define which DORA metrics are included in the scorecard, the specific passing criteria should be set individually for each component, rather than being enforced globally across all components.

            [COMPASS-112] Support for defining scorecard passing criteria at the component level.

            awilkes Thanks, appreciate it - I've booked a slot now. Look forward to discuss  

            Cornelia Jeppsson added a comment - awilkes Thanks, appreciate it - I've booked a slot now. Look forward to discuss  

            488b22bab773 Thanks for the feedback. My goal in closing this quickly was to prevent this from sitting forever because, truthfully, I cannot see a future where we implement per-component thresholds. But I can see how that could be interpreted as overly dismissive; I apologize.

            In fact, I'd love to know more about the problems you are trying to solve. If you're interested in having a converation about this please feel free to set up some time here: https://www.getclockwise.com/c/awilkes-atlassian-com/compass-scorecards

            Alastair Wilkes added a comment - 488b22bab773 Thanks for the feedback. My goal in closing this quickly was to prevent this from sitting forever because, truthfully, I cannot see a future where we implement per-component thresholds. But I can see how that could be interpreted as overly dismissive; I apologize. In fact, I'd love to know more about the problems you are trying to solve. If you're interested in having a converation about this please feel free to set up some time here: https://www.getclockwise.com/c/awilkes-atlassian-com/compass-scorecards

            Cornelia Jeppsson added a comment - - edited

            awilkes Oh, that's quite a bummer, but then I guess each team have to create a bunch of scorecards each. Will be very difficult to help administer, impossible to get the needed overview for all teams in one place for a specific scorecard that we want to have globally, and therefore rendered quite useless for us. I wish you would have taken the time to understand more the needs before dismissing this so quickly (after not even being up for a week).

            Cornelia Jeppsson added a comment - - edited awilkes Oh, that's quite a bummer, but then I guess each team have to create a bunch of scorecards each. Will be very difficult to help administer, impossible to get the needed overview for all teams in one place for a specific scorecard that we want to have globally, and therefore rendered quite useless for us. I wish you would have taken the time to understand more the needs before dismissing this so quickly (after not even being up for a week).
            Alastair Wilkes made changes -
            Status Original: Gathering Interest [ 11772 ] New: Not Being Considered [ 11776 ]

            Thanks for the suggestion. We are unlikely to implement this specific solution becauase scorecards are intended as global policies. I can see this being useful, but it doesn't align with the vision for the feature.

            That said, I do think there is value in letting teams set goals/targets/thresholds for their metrics (outside of the scorecard concept).

            Alastair Wilkes added a comment - Thanks for the suggestion. We are unlikely to implement this specific solution becauase scorecards are intended as global policies. I can see this being useful, but it doesn't align with the vision for the feature. That said, I do think there is value in letting teams set goals/targets/thresholds for their metrics (outside of the scorecard concept).
            SET Analytics Bot made changes -
            Support reference count New: 1
            Alie Sesay created issue -

              Unassigned Unassigned
              941c832d1c72 Alie Sesay
              Votes:
              2 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              5 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated: