Cannot create Application Links to Crucible (defaults to Anonymous)

I recently upgraded Fisheye/Crucible to use Crowd for authentication, but not my JIRA instance yet. Application Links/Auth between the 2 atlassian applications will no longer work.

From a specific JIRA project, I attempt to create an Application Link.

I first get

When I click Authorize I get

And when I allow it I get

I no longer have integration with my 50+ software project and associated repos. This prevents my team from creating reviews in a streamlined fashion and has a major impact on my organization.