-
Type:
Suggestion
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Component/s: None
NOTE: This suggestion is for Confluence Cloud. Using Confluence Server? See the corresponding suggestion.
The editor in 4.2.2 (probably was introduced earlier but our company is just upgrading to 4.x) takes up an excessive amount of vertical space. I'm calling this a bug since I think it’s a bad UX design and should have been thought through.
The title bar, toolbar and lower tool/info bar take up about 250 pixels combined. On a screen where your browser leaves you with 875 vertical pixels of space, the controls for the editor are taking almost 30% of the usable region!!
The title bar is especially excessive. Its uses unnecessarily huge font text. It should be made smaller so that more room can be left for editable region.
Some improvements / specific issues:
- Make the title bar a regular size one-line text region (no formatting)
- Once a table has been added to the document, the table controls in the toolbar are always displayed even if your cursor is not contextually inside of the table.
- The upper and lower toolbars have a lot of padding above and below the buttons. This should be reduced to 1-2 pixels.
- The "Hint / Last Edited" bar should be made optional.
- Ideally combine the last saved information to the lower toolbar (maybe just add a simple time in the "save" button such as "Save (8:14a)"
- Make the hint info completely optional
- Give user choice of having small toolbar buttons that take up less space
- Either give the user or the Space Admin option to customize the buttons that appear in the toolbar
- Move the lower toolbar into the upper toolbar and change the buttons to standard toolbar buttons w/o labels.
- If you feel its needed you can still offer a pref to have toolbar buttons shown with text or not.
- Some apps have a nice 3rd state which shows text on only the buttons which are really deserving of more than a simple icon.
The design of the editor as it stands now is form over function!! I hope that the developers see to making changes to make this app more geared to getting work done efficiently instead of fussing over making sure the UI looks "pretty".
Use case (to demonstrate how the current design impedes):
As it stands now, if I'm writing a spec and I paste an screenshot in that is 600 pixels high, I don't have any room to view the image and type about it. All I need is about 10 lines below the image but now I'm forced to open a new window to preview the image while I type.
btw: I do like how some of the toolbar buttons where combined into multi-function to save space like having the 'insert' and different html controls under that.
- is related to
-
CONFSERVER-25464 Improve editor vertical height usage, especially for smaller screens
- Closed