Uploaded image for project: 'Jira Software Data Center'
  1. Jira Software Data Center
  2. JSWSERVER-14957

The Development "Widget" is showing in project without stash link

    • We collect Jira feedback from various sources, and we evaluate what we've collected when planning our product roadmap. To understand how this piece of feedback will be reviewed, see our Implementation of New Features Policy.

      We have the problem, that in every project the Development "Widget" is showing up, even if the project is connected with stash or not.

      So the Users are creating support request with questions about this "Widget" or with error messages because they do not have access to the stash instance.
      Could you please fix this and disable the Development "Widget" with projects which do not have a project link to stash.

      The same with the Source Tab under activities...

      In our opinion this is clearly a bug.

      Thanks
      Martin

        1. ActivitySourceTab.png
          ActivitySourceTab.png
          12 kB
        2. DevelopmentWidget.png
          DevelopmentWidget.png
          19 kB
        3. projectlink.png
          projectlink.png
          121 kB

            [JSWSERVER-14957] The Development "Widget" is showing in project without stash link

            Thanks for the reply back, Ignat. I saw on answers.atlassian.com where a few people were talking about using the method you describe to attack the problem. They were talking about turning the panel off entirely for certain projects (rather than just hiding the "create branch" link) and seemed to be having mixed success at best. In general, I try to avoid using putting a lot of javascript in the announcement banner just to overcome UI issues in the product anyway.

            For now, I'm trying to get people to just live with it. On the old source tab, we could configure the number of files shown for each commit before it tosses you over to fisheye to see more. I don't see a way to do that here either, which is not helping me make the case that this is an improvement. :-/

            Dave Thomas added a comment - Thanks for the reply back, Ignat. I saw on answers.atlassian.com where a few people were talking about using the method you describe to attack the problem. They were talking about turning the panel off entirely for certain projects (rather than just hiding the "create branch" link) and seemed to be having mixed success at best. In general, I try to avoid using putting a lot of javascript in the announcement banner just to overcome UI issues in the product anyway. For now, I'm trying to get people to just live with it. On the old source tab, we could configure the number of files shown for each commit before it tosses you over to fisheye to see more. I don't see a way to do that here either, which is not helping me make the case that this is an improvement. :-/

            Hi Dave, 

            Unfortunately we are not planning to update the current development panel in the foreseeable future. I've read your comment before where you explain that it's not easy to remove the panel as some developers in your organisation do use the feature.

            The idea is to add a custom field that would execute a javascript and customise the panel for you, i.e. which would allow to hide the panel for some developers.

             This is not officially supported - but can solve the problem for you until you migrate to git.

            Some related links:

            Cheers,
            Ignat
            JIRA Bugmaster.

            Ignat (Inactive) added a comment - Hi Dave,  Unfortunately we are not planning to update the current development panel in the foreseeable future. I've read your comment before where you explain that it's not easy to remove the panel as some developers in your organisation do use the feature. The idea is to add a custom field that would execute a javascript and customise the panel for you, i.e. which would allow to hide the panel for some developers.  This is not officially supported - but can solve the problem for you until you migrate to git. Some related links: https://confluence.atlassian.com/jira062/fields-allowing-custom-html-or-javascript-588581450.html https://answers.atlassian.com/questions/45825/how-to-remove-options-from-a-multi-version-picker-field Cheers, Ignat JIRA Bugmaster.

            Not that anyone will see this, but after two years we finally caved in and enabled the developer panel. We have more teams on git/BitBucket now, so we really wanted the extra functionality provided.

            On the negative side, this issue still hasn't been fixed, so we have to explain to developers who are on projects that are using subversion/fisheye/crucible that they should not click on the "create branch" link. And we also have to explain to all developers in general that we can't suppress the "create branch" link when it shouldn't be shown (i.e. project isn't using BitBucket, or isn't applicable to a certain issue type or status).

            To make matters worse, all the email I'm sending to our developers from Jira on this topic get delivered with messed up sender name thanks to JRA-30224. So half our team thinks Jira's email is some kind of spam or phishing attempt. Really crappy user experience all around, Atlassian.

            Dave Thomas added a comment - Not that anyone will see this, but after two years we finally caved in and enabled the developer panel. We have more teams on git/BitBucket now, so we really wanted the extra functionality provided. On the negative side, this issue still hasn't been fixed, so we have to explain to developers who are on projects that are using subversion/fisheye/crucible that they should not click on the "create branch" link. And we also have to explain to all developers in general that we can't suppress the "create branch" link when it shouldn't be shown (i.e. project isn't using BitBucket, or isn't applicable to a certain issue type or status). To make matters worse, all the email I'm sending to our developers from Jira on this topic get delivered with messed up sender name thanks to JRA-30224 . So half our team thinks Jira's email is some kind of spam or phishing attempt. Really crappy user experience all around, Atlassian.

            DaveT added a comment -

            @Oswaldo - You're missing the point. These ARE projects that are meant to track development. In our case, they use subversion together with fisheye/crucible. They are linked with project level links to the relevant fisheye repositories and crucible projects. And yet... the developer panel contains a link that says "create branch..." that takes the user to stash.

            Apparently, Atlassian has migrated 100% of their repositories to stash, but for those of us who haven't (and are only at the beginning stages of migrating several hundred), this is a highly disruptive bug. Most of our developers don't even have an account on stash at the moment, so they can't login there. And the ones who CAN login are confused about why they should be creating a branch in stash – they keep looking for their (subversion) repository to be there....

            DaveT added a comment - @Oswaldo - You're missing the point. These ARE projects that are meant to track development. In our case, they use subversion together with fisheye/crucible. They are linked with project level links to the relevant fisheye repositories and crucible projects. And yet... the developer panel contains a link that says "create branch..." that takes the user to stash. Apparently, Atlassian has migrated 100% of their repositories to stash, but for those of us who haven't (and are only at the beginning stages of migrating several hundred), this is a highly disruptive bug. Most of our developers don't even have an account on stash at the moment, so they can't login there. And the ones who CAN login are confused about why they should be creating a branch in stash – they keep looking for their (subversion) repository to be there....

            Hi swisscom.scm / circusdog,

            This might be solved by customizing the permission schemes for projects that are not meant to be used to track development.

            Consequently, could you please create a support ticket at https://support.atlassian.com? That way we can provide you with support specific to your circumstances

            The credentials should be the same as for this site (https://jira.atlassian.com).

            Regards,

            Oswaldo Hernández.
            JIRA Bugmaster.
            [Atlassian].

            Oswaldo Hernandez (Inactive) added a comment - Hi swisscom.scm / circusdog , This might be solved by customizing the permission schemes for projects that are not meant to be used to track development. Consequently, could you please create a support ticket at https://support.atlassian.com? That way we can provide you with support specific to your circumstances The credentials should be the same as for this site ( https://jira.atlassian.com ). Regards, Oswaldo Hernández. JIRA Bugmaster. [Atlassian] .

            DaveT added a comment -

            In our environment, we have 300+ projects in jira that are mostly using subversion together with fisheye/crucible. Only a handful of projects are using stash because we're still on the early side of figuring out how we're going to use this and roll it out. When we integrate the stash server with Jira, however, all 300+ projects suddenly get a "create branch" link that takes them to stash. This looks really amateurish and created all kinds of support questions and complaints for us. As a result, we have disabled the developer panel, which really hurts the projects using stash because we'd really like for them to be able to create branches from the link on the jira issue.

            DaveT added a comment - In our environment, we have 300+ projects in jira that are mostly using subversion together with fisheye/crucible. Only a handful of projects are using stash because we're still on the early side of figuring out how we're going to use this and roll it out. When we integrate the stash server with Jira, however, all 300+ projects suddenly get a "create branch" link that takes them to stash. This looks really amateurish and created all kinds of support questions and complaints for us. As a result, we have disabled the developer panel, which really hurts the projects using stash because we'd really like for them to be able to create branches from the link on the jira issue.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              swisscom.scm Martin, SCM Support
              Votes:
              3 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              6 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: