Uploaded image for project: 'Jira Cloud'
  1. Jira Cloud
  2. JSWCLOUD-21855

Allow builds / deployments etc to be removed from an issue

    • 22
    • 5
    • Our product teams collect and evaluate feedback from a number of different sources. To learn more about how we use customer feedback in the planning process, check out our new feature policy.

      Issue Summary

      Sometimes builds / deployments / pull requests etc. can be incorrectly associated with an issue (e.g. used the wrong issue key in a commit)

      It would be good to have the ability to remove those incorrect associations so that the linked data is correct.

       

            [JSWCLOUD-21855] Allow builds / deployments etc to be removed from an issue

            Same issue here, needed to reorganize a ticket and now I can't unlink the PR from the previous ticket and it is messing up all our automation

            Matt Monacelli added a comment - Same issue here, needed to reorganize a ticket and now I can't unlink the PR from the previous ticket and it is messing up all our automation

            François Séguin added a comment - - edited

            jnavin I think that adding

             Workaround

             Currently, there is no workaround.

             

            in the issue would make it visible in https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/JRACLOUD-70206?filter=98153

            François Séguin added a comment - - edited jnavin I think that adding  Workaround  Currently, there is no workaround.   in the issue would make it visible in https://jira.atlassian.com/browse/JRACLOUD-70206?filter=98153

            we would also like this feature

            Christopher Gordon added a comment - we would also like this feature

            I hit the same issue filed in this ticket. I amended the commit message and inserted the correct ID, but, the old commit stays lingering in the ticket with the message: "This commit does not belong to any branch on this repository, and may belong to a fork outside of the repository". A fix to this is much appreciated.

            Rachida Kebichi added a comment - I hit the same issue filed in this ticket. I amended the commit message and inserted the correct ID, but, the old commit stays lingering in the ticket with the message: "This commit does not belong to any branch on this repository, and may belong to a fork outside of the repository". A fix to this is much appreciated.

            This fix would be very helpful. 

            Vasilis Zarmpalas added a comment - This fix would be very helpful. 

            This has caused a lot of headache, please fix 

            Konstantinos Pantelis added a comment - This has caused a lot of headache, please fix 

            +1

            +1

            Byron Gkirkas added a comment - +1

            +1

             

            Dimitris Bousoulas added a comment - +1  

            +1

            +1

            mmamalakis added a comment -

            +1

            mmamalakis added a comment - +1

            +1. I think it is own of the most common pains for lots of development teams. 

            Kostas Papageorgopoulos added a comment - +1. I think it is own of the most common pains for lots of development teams. 

            +1

            Jimmy Pruitt added a comment - +1

            Erik added a comment -

            +1

            Erik added a comment - +1

            +1

            Zainab Ottun added a comment - +1

            +1

            +1

            Felipe Corso added a comment - +1

            +1

            Actually the situation can also come up when a pull request target branch is changed.  No idea why, but this triggers all commits in between the branches to be linked.  Less than ideal.  

             

            > Based on Atlassian's lead time, this would be available around 2028?

             
            Optimistic it will actually get addressed at all aren't you

            Steve Ebersole added a comment - Actually the situation can also come up when a pull request target branch is changed.  No idea why, but this triggers all commits in between the branches to be linked.  Less than ideal.     > Based on Atlassian's lead time, this would be available around 2028?   Optimistic it will actually get addressed at all aren't you

            sviridi added a comment -

            +1

            sviridi added a comment - +1

            +1

            Please, I just encountered an issue where the branch name is associated with the Jira key and branch name cannot be updated. 

            +1

            Aman Sinha added a comment - Please, I just encountered an issue where the branch name is associated with the Jira key and branch name cannot be updated.  +1

            +1

            shravani.roy added a comment - +1

            really weird not to have un-link feature, 

            pankaj_gagain added a comment - really weird not to have un-link feature, 

            +1 to this, it is very annoying not to be able to unlink.

            Oliver.Larkin added a comment - +1 to this, it is very annoying not to be able to unlink.

            +1, We are having this problem too.

            Stacey Campbell added a comment - +1, We are having this problem too.

            Tony McGrath added a comment - - edited

            As we are all human, occasionally a mistake is made when entering the Jira ticket number to a commit or PR in GitHub, and so an incorrect association is made. Currently that is a permanent association. This is problematic for audit and traceability reasons.

            This means that the Jira tools with GitHub integration cannot be used to comply with ISO (and other) standards, which generally demand traceability for all edits to a software base. All for the sake of what must be a small fix.

            Surely it would be easy to add support for directives at the GitHub end, e.g. entering RemovePR:ABC-123 in a PR description will remove the link.

            Please look into fixing this issue.

            Tony McGrath added a comment - - edited As we are all human, occasionally a mistake is made when entering the Jira ticket number to a commit or PR in GitHub, and so an incorrect association is made. Currently that is a permanent association. This is problematic for audit and traceability reasons. This means that the Jira tools with GitHub integration cannot be used to comply with ISO (and other) standards, which generally demand traceability for all edits to a software base. All for the sake of what must be a small fix. Surely it would be easy to add support for directives at the GitHub end, e.g. entering RemovePR:ABC-123 in a PR description will remove the link. Please look into fixing this issue.

            +1. This comes up very often. After removing the errant reference to a ticket number from a PR, it'd really help to have a way to remove the link to that PR from the ticket.

            Ben Chandler added a comment - +1. This comes up very often. After removing the errant reference to a ticket number from a PR, it'd really help to have a way to remove the link to that PR from the ticket.

            dtlhlbs added a comment -

            Based on Atlassian's lead time, this would be available around 2028?

            dtlhlbs added a comment - Based on Atlassian's lead time, this would be available around 2028?

            Come on guys, this is pretty ridiculous that this basic feature is not available in 2023.

            Sorin Preda (Extern) added a comment - Come on guys, this is pretty ridiculous that this basic feature is not available in 2023.

            Please! Fat fingers are messing up all automations. 

            Jennifer Pfening added a comment - Please! Fat fingers are messing up all automations. 

            +1

            gbrown added a comment -

            +1, please allow this.

            gbrown added a comment - +1, please allow this.

            This would be a good feature to add whenever possible. We all sometimes add a wrong PR to a Jira ticket and need a way to undo our fat-finger mistakes.

            Gaurav Aggarwal added a comment - This would be a good feature to add whenever possible. We all sometimes add a wrong PR to a Jira ticket and need a way to undo our fat-finger mistakes.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              jnavin James Navin
              Votes:
              119 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              66 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated: