Uploaded image for project: 'Jira Data Center'
  1. Jira Data Center
  2. JRASERVER-40192

JIRA's email FROM field is sending from a wrong address

      *Type GG > Mail > Outgoing Mail

      • Configure a mail server (e.g mail server address is annamonicacardino@gmail.com)
      • Type GG > Mail > Send E-mail
      • Notice that the FROM field is the current user's email address and not the mail server address.
      • Click SEND
      • When you received the email, the FROM field is not showing the current user's email address but the mail server's address.

        1. bug_1.jpg
          bug_1.jpg
          54 kB
        2. bug_2.jpg
          bug_2.jpg
          75 kB
        3. bug_3.jpg
          bug_3.jpg
          48 kB
        4. jira_emails.jpg
          jira_emails.jpg
          21 kB
        5. jira_reply.jpg
          jira_reply.jpg
          5 kB
        6. mail_1.jpg
          mail_1.jpg
          92 kB
        7. mail_2.jpg
          mail_2.jpg
          41 kB
        8. mail_3.jpg
          mail_3.jpg
          51 kB

            [JRASERVER-40192] JIRA's email FROM field is sending from a wrong address

            Hi acardino,

            This is because Gmail prevents the from address to be set to anything different from you account name moniqueanna27 . This is an email spoofing prevention technique done at the email service provider side (Yahoo and other public servers do this as well).

            JIRA tries to set the from address to what you specified but it can't do much is the mail service provider (gmail) overrides this.

            Hope that clears up what you saw.

            Regards,

            Oswaldo Hernández.
            JIRA Bugmaster.
            [Atlassian].

            Oswaldo Hernandez (Inactive) added a comment - Hi acardino , This is because Gmail prevents the from address to be set to anything different from you account name moniqueanna27 . This is an email spoofing prevention technique done at the email service provider side (Yahoo and other public servers do this as well). JIRA tries to set the from address to what you specified but it can't do much is the mail service provider (gmail) overrides this. Hope that clears up what you saw. Regards, Oswaldo Hernández. JIRA Bugmaster. [Atlassian] .

            chip yglesia added a comment - - edited

            I attempted to reply to the updates from Monique Cardino upon the reopening of this jira. But I think bc of the very problem John mentioned it never made it to the case. I will copy/paste my email below. Then attach the files mentioned in the copy/paste of the email:
            <<---Begin Paste -->>
            See “jira_emails.jpg” (attached) for the issue John Ceraolo is asking about. While I was typing “jira” you see it auto completes with email addresses that belong to the jira instance....not those actual users...reversely, if I begin typing any of those names in, I have to be very mindful NOT to choose those bad entries over the person’s real email address. In addition to what is obviously an issue is also that if my co-worker comments on a ticket, and if a user has my email tagged to jira...they think it is me updating them.

            Also just noticed in this very reply...all I did was go to the email notification and hit “Reply All” ...and see my “To...” field, as attched “jira_reply.jpg”.

            cheers
            -Chip

            <<--End Paste -->>

            chip yglesia added a comment - - edited I attempted to reply to the updates from Monique Cardino upon the reopening of this jira. But I think bc of the very problem John mentioned it never made it to the case. I will copy/paste my email below. Then attach the files mentioned in the copy/paste of the email: <<---Begin Paste -->> See “jira_emails.jpg” (attached) for the issue John Ceraolo is asking about. While I was typing “jira” you see it auto completes with email addresses that belong to the jira instance....not those actual users...reversely, if I begin typing any of those names in, I have to be very mindful NOT to choose those bad entries over the person’s real email address. In addition to what is obviously an issue is also that if my co-worker comments on a ticket, and if a user has my email tagged to jira...they think it is me updating them. Also just noticed in this very reply...all I did was go to the email notification and hit “Reply All” ...and see my “To...” field, as attched “jira_reply.jpg”. cheers -Chip <<--End Paste -->>

            Am guessing this is more of an outlook behavior issue. Very frustrating. But perhaps worth opening case with Atlassian to address this specifically.

            chip yglesia added a comment - Am guessing this is more of an outlook behavior issue. Very frustrating. But perhaps worth opening case with Atlassian to address this specifically.

            I can assure you, no it has not. BTW, I use Atlassian Cloud...

            John Ceraolo added a comment - I can assure you, no it has not. BTW, I use Atlassian Cloud...

            Was John Ceraolo's concern addressed in the fix provided?

            chip yglesia added a comment - Was John Ceraolo's concern addressed in the fix provided?

            Eric Dain added a comment -

            yes yes YES. This has been plaguing us recently, and it is causing much confusion for folks who (rightly!) have no reason to think Outlook would be mis-associating a previous user to a new email notification. It's very pernicious!

            Thank you for looking into this.

            -Eric

            Eric Dain added a comment - yes yes YES. This has been plaguing us recently, and it is causing much confusion for folks who (rightly!) have no reason to think Outlook would be mis-associating a previous user to a new email notification. It's very pernicious! Thank you for looking into this. -Eric

            Thank You,
            Very appreciated

            Olle Friman added a comment - Thank You, Very appreciated

            Hi ollfri,

            This should be a relatively simple fix and has generated customer interest, so I have added this to our backlog.

            Regards,

            Oswaldo Hernández.
            JIRA Bugmaster.
            [Atlassian].

            Oswaldo Hernandez (Inactive) added a comment - Hi ollfri , This should be a relatively simple fix and has generated customer interest, so I have added this to our backlog. Regards, Oswaldo Hernández. JIRA Bugmaster. [Atlassian] .

            We have several users that are very upset over this bug.
            Is it possible you can prioritize it?

            Olle Friman added a comment - We have several users that are very upset over this bug. Is it possible you can prioritize it?

            One thing I have noticed in our use of Outlook/Exchange, if a user is sending email to us about a ticket status, he will now have his name associated with either Jira or Confluence. So for example if you have a Joe Smith working with you at Companyx.com and his email address is part of your corporate address book, he should appear as "Joe Smith" and when you start typing his name in the "To:" field of an email, he will autocomplete. However, if he just sent a Jira update (or Confluence), he will appear as "Joe Smith (Jira)" and the address will be companyx.atlassian.net - which is totally bizarre. Even if you create a Jira and Confluence address pointing to Atlassian, the "Joe Smith (Jira)" will autocomplete for you when you start typing "Jira". For point of reference this is Outlook and the OnDemand version. In all cases, this has been the address for me that shows up for subsequent Jira updates (Joe Smith) until someone else sends me an update. You can also call your other users and ask them to start typing Jira in their "To:" field, and they will likely have a different username show up. So there is something relevant here (IMHO) as to why this is happening...

            John Ceraolo added a comment - One thing I have noticed in our use of Outlook/Exchange, if a user is sending email to us about a ticket status, he will now have his name associated with either Jira or Confluence. So for example if you have a Joe Smith working with you at Companyx.com and his email address is part of your corporate address book, he should appear as "Joe Smith" and when you start typing his name in the "To:" field of an email, he will autocomplete. However, if he just sent a Jira update (or Confluence), he will appear as "Joe Smith (Jira)" and the address will be companyx.atlassian.net - which is totally bizarre. Even if you create a Jira and Confluence address pointing to Atlassian, the "Joe Smith (Jira)" will autocomplete for you when you start typing "Jira". For point of reference this is Outlook and the OnDemand version. In all cases, this has been the address for me that shows up for subsequent Jira updates (Joe Smith) until someone else sends me an update. You can also call your other users and ask them to start typing Jira in their "To:" field, and they will likely have a different username show up. So there is something relevant here (IMHO) as to why this is happening...

              ohernandez@atlassian.com Oswaldo Hernandez (Inactive)
              acardino Anna Cardino (Inactive)
              Affected customers:
              11 This affects my team
              Watchers:
              20 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: