Uploaded image for project: 'JIRA'
  1. JIRA
  2. JRA-3228

Ability to add versions to components

        Details

        • Feedback Policy:

          JIRA feedback is collected from a number of different sources and is evaluated when planning the product roadmap. If you would like to know more about how JIRA Product Management uses customer input during the planning process, please see our post on Atlassian Answers.

          Description

          In many projects the components get released seperately and so need their own version numbers. Project versions then become a list of the components at their particular version numbers.

            Issue Links

            is duplicated by

            Suggestion - JRA-3501 Allow Versions of components

            • Open

            Suggestion - JRA-18987 Managing multiple versions of a component

            • Closed
            is incorporated by

            Suggestion - JRA-12241 Support for Product Suites / Sub-Projects

            • Closed
            mentioned in

            Page Loading...

              Activity

              Ascending order - Click to sort in descending order
              19 older comments
              Hide
              Permalink
              bandersson Bjorn Andersson added a comment - - edited

              This is a huge deal to us and we are a big user (enterprise edition). Per Björn Schormann's comments, we CANNOT deal with different components as separate projects, it would just make things even more difficult. What mechanisms exist for raising the priority of this issue? This is a very fundamental feature required by many of us, even though the voting may not reflect it.
              I agree JRA-1962 is important as well, but to us, not any more so than this.

              Show
              bandersson Bjorn Andersson added a comment - - edited This is a huge deal to us and we are a big user (enterprise edition). Per Björn Schormann's comments, we CANNOT deal with different components as separate projects, it would just make things even more difficult. What mechanisms exist for raising the priority of this issue? This is a very fundamental feature required by many of us, even though the voting may not reflect it. I agree JRA-1962 is important as well, but to us, not any more so than this.
              Hide
              Permalink
              bjoern.schormann Björn Schormann added a comment -

              Hi Mr. Andersson,
              as I mentioned before I am quite a bit full of doubt that this issue ever will be up in priority. It seems to be more like a sort of

              • "this really should be done but first I have to do...."
              • "this really should be done by someone but I don't just have the time"
              • etc.

              Beside when you take a look at the votes of the relating issues:

              you sum up to > 700 votes.

              I personally would not mind if you send a memo to the users in your company that encourages those, that really suffer by the lack that feature, to sign up at this JIRA instance and vote for it.

              One thing is for sure: the desperate needs of many many users for now over 7 (in words SEVEN) years, is obviously not an argument to get the job done. Maybe a huge numbers of voters will be? Who knows but what else could we do?

              Show
              bjoern.schormann Björn Schormann added a comment - Hi Mr. Andersson, as I mentioned before I am quite a bit full of doubt that this issue ever will be up in priority. It seems to be more like a sort of "this really should be done but first I have to do...." "this really should be done by someone but I don't just have the time" etc. Beside when you take a look at the votes of the relating issues: JRA-12241 : 309 JRA-3501 : 208 JRA-2744 : 208 and this one: 74 you sum up to > 700 votes. I personally would not mind if you send a memo to the users in your company that encourages those, that really suffer by the lack that feature, to sign up at this JIRA instance and vote for it. One thing is for sure: the desperate needs of many many users for now over 7 (in words SEVEN) years, is obviously not an argument to get the job done. Maybe a huge numbers of voters will be? Who knows but what else could we do?
              Hide
              Permalink
              arantxa.lacasa Arantxa Lacasa Madero added a comment -

              Please, aproach this!!

              Show
              arantxa.lacasa Arantxa Lacasa Madero added a comment - Please, aproach this!!
              Hide
              Permalink
              denizoguz Deniz Oguz added a comment -

              We have developed a JIRA plugin that allows component specific version numbers. It enforces component specific versions on issue create, edit, inline edit and workflow screens. You can check it out at Atlassian Marketplace (Component and Bundle Versions for JIRA) or at read the plug-in's help page for more detailed manual. This Plugin also allows you to group different versions of different components into one bundle. At issue creation page, if you do not select any component, this plugin only allows you to select bundle version numbers. It also provides two new JQL functions (affectsBundle and fixedInBundle) to query issues affecting a bundle. We welcome any feedbacks.

              Show
              denizoguz Deniz Oguz added a comment - We have developed a JIRA plugin that allows component specific version numbers. It enforces component specific versions on issue create, edit, inline edit and workflow screens. You can check it out at Atlassian Marketplace (Component and Bundle Versions for JIRA) or at read the plug-in's help page for more detailed manual. This Plugin also allows you to group different versions of different components into one bundle. At issue creation page, if you do not select any component, this plugin only allows you to select bundle version numbers. It also provides two new JQL functions (affectsBundle and fixedInBundle) to query issues affecting a bundle. We welcome any feedbacks.
              Hide
              Permalink
              dmeyer Dave Meyer added a comment -

              This is a duplicate of JRA-3501, we would like to consolidate discussion of this feature on that issue.

              Show
              dmeyer Dave Meyer added a comment - This is a duplicate of JRA-3501 , we would like to consolidate discussion of this feature on that issue.

                People

                • Assignee:
                  Unassigned
                  Reporter:
                  jneale John Neale
                • Votes:
                  120 Vote for this issue
                  Watchers:
                  60 Start watching this issue

                  Dates

                  • Created:
                    Updated:
                    Resolved: