-
Bug
-
Resolution: Not a bug
-
Low
-
None
-
7.4.2
-
None
-
Severity 3 - Minor
Issue Summary
When using the OR smart values on the Fix Version field, it doesn't return the right results.
This is reproducible on Data Center: (yes)
Steps to Reproduce
- Create a new issue and add the Version 1.0 value to the Fix Version field.
- Create a new Automation rule with "Manually triggered" and add the "Edit Issue" on the action.
- Choose to update the Description field with the syntax below.
- Paste the smart syntax in the rule actions:
* issue.fixVersions.name.equals("Version 1.0"): {{issue.fixVersions.name.equals("Version 1.0")}} * or(issue.fixVersions.name.equals("Version 1.0"), false): {{or(issue.fixVersions.name.equals("Version 1.0"), false)}} * or(issue.fixVersions.first.name.equals("Version 1.0"), false): {{or(issue.fixVersions.first.name.equals("Version 1.0"), false)}}
- Publish the changes.
- The results we get is this:
Expected Results
Based on the OR logic:
or(issue.fixVersions.name.equals("Version 1.0"), false)
When comparing true or false, we should get true instead of false.
Actual Results
The results returned false instead comparing true OR false logic.
Workaround
Add a .first syntax:
or(issue.fixVersions.first.name.equals("Version 1.0"), false)
- relates to
-
![[JIRA Server (Bulldog)]](/images/icons/generic_link_16.png "[JIRA Server (Bulldog)]")
A4J-3005
You do not have permission to view this issue
[JIRAAUTOSERVER-481] When using OR syntax in FixVersion field, it doesn't return correct results
displayed result of
{{issue.fixVersions.name.equals("Version 1.0")}}
is iteration over all names in the collection, that's why for one element collection the displayed text looks like single result.
To properly observe difference please check following smart value:
This is original one: * issue.fixVersions.name.equals("v1.0.0"): {{issue.fixVersions.name.equals("v1.0.0")}} * or(issue.fixVersions.name.equals("v1.0.0"), false): {{or(issue.fixVersions.name.equals("v1.0.0"), false)}} * or(issue.fixVersions.first.name.equals("v1.0.0"), false): {{or(issue.fixVersions.first.name.equals("v1.0.0"), false)}} Iterating through fixVersions {{#issue.fixVersions}} * current version name: *{{name}}* ** name.equals("v1.0.0"): {{name.equals("v1.0.0")}} ** or(name.equals("v1.0.0"), false):{{or(name.equals("v1.0.0"), false)}} {{/}}
For the Issue where just single fix version is set the result is:
In case of the issue where multiple fix versions are set, the result is
Regards
Daniel Ramotowski
| Attachment | New: result_multiple_versions.png [ 422919 ] |
| Attachment | New: result_1_version_set.png [ 422918 ] |
| Attachment | Original: result_multiple_versions.png [ 422914 ] |
| Attachment | Original: result_1_version_set.png [ 422913 ] |
| Attachment | New: result_multiple_versions.png [ 422914 ] |
| Attachment | New: result_1_version_set.png [ 422913 ] |
Wait a second.
In bug report it is stated that
issue.fixVersions.name.equals("Version 1.0")
returns true, not false, as you say.
So,
or(issue.fixVersions.name.equals("Version 1.0"), false)
should return true.
| Resolution | New: Not a bug [ 12 ] | |
| Status | Original: Needs Triage [ 10030 ] | New: Closed [ 6 ] |
I see now. I was thinking for some reason that this single fix version will be casted to string and will be compared as a string.