Summary

Restricted page lock icon displays as unlocked when there is only edit restrictions on a page

Environment

• Confluence 5.9+

Steps to Reproduce

1. Create a page in Confluence 5.9 or above
2. Click on the lock icon to edit restrictions
3. Choose 'Editing restricted' from the drop-down
4. Add some editing restrictions
5. Click 'Apply'

Expected Results

As long as there are any restrictions (whether view or edit or both), this icon should display as locked/red. When testing this on a Confluence 5.8 and 5.7 instance, adding either viewing or editing restrictions to a page will change the icon to a red lock. You do not need both restrictions for the icon to change.

Actual Results

Lock icon still displays as grey and unlocked. This can be misleading, as there are certain restrictions. A potential solution would be to have an intermediate icon that would display as grey and locked. See attached images for reference.

Notes

If this was a design decision, then this will not be a bug. I'd just like to clarify whether this was an intentional decision or if this was done unintentionally.

Workaround

There is no workaround at this point.