User-friendly notification on failure to auto-save

XMLWordPrintable

    • Type: Suggestion
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • 2.8
    • Component/s: None

      The AJAX-ified auto-save functionality in Confluence's editing panel rocks. However, there is one major issue, especially when using IE.

      Scenario to replicate is as follows:

      1) Click 'Edit' on any given page
      2) Edit away, confident that auto-save is saving your ass every 30 seconds or so.
      3) one way or another, and unbeknownst to you, lose your connection to the box hosting Confluence (VPN-timeout is an excellent way to make this happen)
      4) After you're done editing, say 30 minutes and 1000 words later, click 'Save'.
      5) Cry yourself to sleep after realizing your work is GONE and there were no auto-saves thanks to your crappy VPN connection. (no, hitting that back button isn't going to help you either).

      Now, the Firefox-vs-IE issue is this: When an auto-save operation fails in Firefox, you see a modal dialog appear with a (totally cryptic) Javascript message. While this message is impenetrable to the average user, it nevertheless lets them know 'hey - something is probably wrong here'. The smart user might think to make a safe copy of their content at this point. In IE, however, the error is swallowed, making it transparent to the user. This just proved to be a painful problem for one of our employees.

      The solution? I'd like to see a user-friendly event in the UI that lets one know that auto-save just failed. This could be via a yellow alert box appearing somewhere in the UI, much like the 'would you like to resume the draft you started on <date>' blue box that appears above the edit textarea. It could also be implemented as a pop-up window or just a more human-readable javascript alert.

              Assignee:
              Matt Ryall
              Reporter:
              Chris Beams
              Votes:
              5 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              2 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: