• Icon: Suggestion Suggestion
    • Resolution: Obsolete
    • None
    • Stride
    • None
    • 7
    • 5
    • Our product teams collect and evaluate feedback from a number of different sources. To learn more about how we use customer feedback in the planning process, check out our new feature policy.

      Bamboo currently has good support for sending various notifications to HipChat.

      Now that Atlassian's Stride is on the scene, it would make sense for Bamboo to support similar notifications to this new chat service as well.

            [BAM-18729] Support Stride notifications

            Atlassian Update – [27 July 2018]

            Hi everyone,

            Thank you for your votes and thoughts on this issue.

            We believe the best way forward for our customers and for Atlassian is to enter into a strategic partnership with Slack and no longer offer our own real-time communications products. See full announcement here.

            To learn more on how your suggestions are reviewed, see our updated workflow for server feature suggestions.

            Kind regards,

            Bamboo Team

            Krystian Brazulewicz added a comment - Atlassian Update – [27 July 2018] Hi everyone, Thank you for your votes and thoughts on this issue. We believe the best way forward for our customers and for Atlassian is to enter into a strategic partnership with Slack and no longer offer our own real-time communications products. See full announcement here . To learn more on how your suggestions are reviewed, see our updated workflow for server feature suggestions . Kind regards, Bamboo Team

            neoscorpe yes the timing here was not fortunate. At the moment of defining FY19 roadmap Bamboo team was not aware of this strategic decision.
            Also as you might expect from organisation of Atlassian size such decisions are communicated to all employees at the very late stage.

            Krystian Brazulewicz added a comment - neoscorpe yes the timing here was not fortunate. At the moment of defining FY19 roadmap Bamboo team was not aware of this strategic decision. Also as you might expect from organisation of Atlassian size such decisions are communicated to all employees at the very late stage.

            Black Hat added a comment -

            This is truly astounding. 10 days after announcing they'll "prioritise Stride notifications on Bamboo roadmap", Atlassian completely abandons Stride.

            Seems like the left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing. 

            Black Hat added a comment - This is truly astounding. 10 days after announcing they'll "prioritise Stride notifications on Bamboo roadmap", Atlassian completely abandons Stride . Seems like the left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing. 

            Now, I'm making some assumptions saying this, but:

            I think we do good to consider that the Stride Development/Management Team and the Bamboo Development/Management are likely two separate groups of people (and likewise with JIRA/BitBucket). With this in mind, these latter folks may have had no influence of when, and bearing what features, HipChat is being forcibly replaced with Stride. This means their existing plugin instantly becomes obsolete and new work is automatically piled onto the Backlog which doesn't create any cool new features, it just restores a pretty elaborate existing one. Being a developer myself, I know that scenario would be extremely frustrating to me.

            This all being said, I hope the launch of Stride happened in coordination and cooperation with these other teams, and I hope the Stride team is prioritizing support for their fellow Atlassian colleagues.

            I'd love to hear from someone at Atlassian whether this is close to or far from the truth.

            Ricardo van den Broek added a comment - Now, I'm making some assumptions saying this, but: I think we do good to consider that the Stride Development/Management Team and the Bamboo Development/Management are likely two separate groups of people (and likewise with JIRA/BitBucket). With this in mind, these latter folks may have had no influence of when, and bearing what features, HipChat is being forcibly replaced with Stride. This means their existing plugin instantly becomes obsolete and new work is automatically piled onto the Backlog which doesn't create any cool new features, it just restores a pretty elaborate existing one. Being a developer myself, I know that scenario would be extremely frustrating to me. This all being said, I hope the launch of Stride happened in coordination and cooperation with these other teams, and I hope the Stride team is prioritizing support for their fellow Atlassian colleagues. I'd love to hear from someone at Atlassian whether this is close to or far from the truth.

            Thank you for the follow-up, Krystian. I hope to hear another update soon.

            One of the most compelling reasons we use Atlassian products here is because of their integration with each other. We started with JIRA, years ago. That soon led to using Confluence, too. Then we started using HipChat instead of Google chat/hangouts... then replaced svn with BitBucket... then replaced Hudson with Bamboo... and each step of the way, a big motivation was the ability to have better connections between the information in each of these systems.

            Scott Moore added a comment - Thank you for the follow-up, Krystian. I hope to hear another update soon. One of the most compelling reasons we use Atlassian products here is because of their integration with each other. We started with JIRA, years ago. That soon led to using Confluence, too. Then we started using HipChat instead of Google chat/hangouts... then replaced svn with BitBucket... then replaced Hudson with Bamboo... and each step of the way, a big motivation was the ability to have better connections between the information in each of these systems.

            Black Hat added a comment -

            After careful consideration, we've decided to prioritise Stride notifications on Bamboo roadmap.

            It's amazing that something like this needed "careful consideration". It's should have been a no-brainer right from the start. Or maybe Atlassian doesn't have a lot of faith in Stride....

            Expect to hear an update on our progress within the next 6 months.

            So it'll more than 12 months since Stride was launched, and there still won't be Bamboo integration? Incredible.

            Black Hat added a comment - After careful consideration, we've decided to prioritise Stride notifications on Bamboo roadmap. It's amazing that something like this needed "careful consideration". It's should have been a no-brainer right from the start. Or maybe Atlassian doesn't have a lot of faith in Stride.... Expect to hear an update on our progress within the next 6 months. So it'll more than 12 months since Stride was launched, and there still won't be Bamboo integration? Incredible.

            Krystian Brazulewicz added a comment - - edited
            Atlassian Update – [17 July 2018]

            Hi everyone,

            Thank you for your votes and thoughts on this issue.

            We fully understand that many of you are dependent on this functionality.

            After careful consideration, we've decided to prioritise Stride notifications on Bamboo roadmap. We hope to start development after our current projects are completed.

            Expect to hear an update on our progress within the next 6 months.

            To learn more on how your suggestions are reviewed, see our updated workflow for server feature suggestions.

            Kind regards,

            Bamboo Team

            Krystian Brazulewicz added a comment - - edited Atlassian Update – [17 July 2018] Hi everyone, Thank you for your votes and thoughts on this issue. We fully understand that many of you are dependent on this functionality. After careful consideration, we've decided to prioritise Stride notifications on Bamboo roadmap. We hope to start development after our current projects are completed. Expect to hear an update on our progress within the next 6 months. To learn more on how your suggestions are reviewed, see our updated workflow for server feature suggestions . Kind regards, Bamboo Team

            Is anyone at Atlassian actually paying attention to this issue?

            I just looked through the comments on this issue and related issue STRIDE-1956 and it seems that it is the Bamboo/Stride user community is upvoting and talking a lot about an integration between two Atlassian products they'd like to see (or more than just "like to see"–they need in order to move to Stride), with zero responses or input from an Atlassian employee.

            Maybe we should pursue this issue through Atlassian Support instead.

            (Thank you, Pavels, for providing a third-party solution in the meantime. It's a little more complicated than using a built-in integration, and as with any third-party integration, I'm concerned about the possibility of it breaking when Bamboo or Stride gets updated.)

            Scott Moore added a comment - Is anyone at Atlassian actually paying attention to this issue? I just looked through the comments on this issue and related issue STRIDE-1956 and it seems that it is the Bamboo/Stride user community is upvoting and talking a lot about an integration between two Atlassian products they'd like to see (or more than just "like to see"–they need in order to move to Stride), with zero responses or input from an Atlassian employee. Maybe we should pursue this issue through Atlassian Support instead. (Thank you, Pavels, for providing a third-party solution in the meantime. It's a little more complicated than using a built-in integration, and as with any third-party integration, I'm concerned about the possibility of it breaking when Bamboo or Stride gets updated.)

            You can use my notification plugin while waiting for official Atlassian support: https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/com.pfyod.bamboo.plugins.bamboo-stride

            Pavels Fjodorovs added a comment - You can use my notification plugin while waiting for official Atlassian support:  https://marketplace.atlassian.com/plugins/com.pfyod.bamboo.plugins.bamboo-stride

            Come on guys, why is this still not available... don't replace a product with another one if simple features like this one aren't available...

            Jurgen Rutten added a comment - Come on guys, why is this still not available... don't replace a product with another one if simple features like this one aren't available...

            Ryan Gay added a comment -

            We use HipChat as the real time communications hub for our product development. We want to switch to Stride, but it simply has to integrate with JIRA, Bamboo, and Bitbucket for it to be effective. This can't possibly be Low priority!

            Ryan Gay added a comment - We use HipChat as the real time communications hub for our product development. We want to switch to Stride, but it simply has to integrate with JIRA, Bamboo, and Bitbucket for it to be effective. This can't possibly be Low priority!

            Quite simply, why wouldn't you integrate with Bamboo, Bitbucket, Jira etc? Like others we would not transition to Stride until these features are in place.

            Mark Oldridge added a comment - Quite simply, why wouldn't you integrate with Bamboo, Bitbucket, Jira etc? Like others we would not transition to Stride until these features are in place.

            One more vote for raising the priority of this

            Deleted Account (Inactive) added a comment - One more vote for raising the priority of this

            This issue is very important to our team at Decision Lens. We probably won't move from Hipchat to Stride until this is available.

            Scott Moore added a comment - This issue is very important to our team at Decision Lens. We probably won't move from Hipchat to Stride until this is available.

            We were moved to Stride not long ago and I only just realized this means no more updates from our Bamboo, BitBucket, JIRA and Confluence applications! (All these we run the Server version of.) If I would have known this I would have waited. I find it very odd that there's no integration between these applications that are from the same vendor! These other products would be the first ones I would expect to have integration with Stride. Why can I integrate with GitHub, but not with Atlassian BitBucket Server? Why can I search for and send animated gifs, but can't get a simple notification when a build breaks in Atlassian Bamboo Server? Maybe it's just me, but that sounds preposterous, especially since this functionality is there in HipChat!

            Ricardo van den Broek added a comment - We were moved to Stride not long ago and I only just realized this means no more updates from our Bamboo, BitBucket, JIRA and Confluence applications! (All these we run the Server version of.) If I would have known this I would have waited. I find it very odd that there's no integration between these applications that are from the same vendor! These other products would be the first ones I would expect to have integration with Stride. Why can I integrate with GitHub, but not with Atlassian BitBucket Server? Why can I search for and send animated gifs, but can't get a simple notification when a build breaks in Atlassian Bamboo Server? Maybe it's just me, but that sounds preposterous, especially since this functionality is there in HipChat!

            Good job! I'll try this plugin as soon as Atlasssian is ready to migrate us to stride (and that's also taking ages).

            Joost Van den Cruyce added a comment - Good job! I'll try this plugin as soon as Atlasssian is ready to migrate us to stride (and that's also taking ages).

            Since Atlassian are taking ages to implement this basic functionality, I've ported an existing open-source Slack notification plugin to support sending notifications to Stride. You are all welcome to take it for a spin: https://bitbucket.org/pfyod/bamboo-stride-plugin

            Pavels Fjodorovs added a comment - Since Atlassian are taking ages to implement this basic functionality, I've ported an existing open-source Slack notification plugin to support sending notifications to Stride. You are all welcome to take it for a spin: https://bitbucket.org/pfyod/bamboo-stride-plugin

            Any update on this? We will be migrated to Stride soon and this is causing us to consider other options.

            Savio Neville Spiteri added a comment - Any update on this? We will be migrated to Stride soon and this is causing us to consider other options.

            +1

            Myke added a comment -

            think the priority of this issue should be at least a medium as many teams that would like to migrate to Stride and use this feature simply can't at this time. Just my 2 cents though.

            Myke added a comment - think the priority of this issue should be at least a medium as many teams that would like to migrate to Stride and use this feature simply can't at this time. Just my 2 cents though.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              mknight@atlassian.com Michael Knight
              Votes:
              90 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              75 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: