• Icon: Suggestion Suggestion
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • 4.4.0
    • Tests
    • None
    • Our product teams collect and evaluate feedback from a number of different sources. To learn more about how we use customer feedback in the planning process, check out our new feature policy.

      We are running unit tests which include some test cases with incomplete and skipped tests ... those are being marked incomplete or skipped.

      Bamboo unfortunately marks such builds as failed!

      The reason for marking a test incomplete or skipped is to tell we don't have a successful case, but it doesn't have any error.

      We would need Bamboo to not behave like we would have a failing build.

      Could you please support / implement the usage of incomplete / skipped tests? This feature is very urgent for our software development process.

      Bet regards,
      Max Horváth

            [BAM-1699] Support for incomplete and skipped tests

            Krystian Brazulewicz added a comment - - edited

            Bamboo supports skipped tests for all supported test parsers.

            Krystian Brazulewicz added a comment - - edited Bamboo supports skipped tests for all supported test parsers.

            Since bamboo depends on the JUnit format (presumably version 3.x) for reporting they can't support incomplete or skipped tests.

            But there are disscusion about extending the format on the apache ant (the format owners) website

            Remko van Bezooijen added a comment - Since bamboo depends on the JUnit format (presumably version 3.x) for reporting they can't support incomplete or skipped tests. But there are disscusion about extending the format on the apache ant (the format owners ) website

            Mark

            The log and some additional comments from me are attached to the original support request.

            https://support.atlassian.com/browse/BSP-3650

            Thanks for looking into this.

            Miro

            Miro Lehky [Metron] added a comment - Mark The log and some additional comments from me are attached to the original support request. https://support.atlassian.com/browse/BSP-3650 Thanks for looking into this. Miro

            MarkC added a comment -

            Miro,

            tests failed due to an exception

            From our internal tests that fail with an exception generally gets marked with an ERROR and does get picked up by Bamboo. We'd originally decided to skip the skipped tests since we didn't think them to be important.

            If tests that failed with an Exception are being skipped, then this certainly more critical.

            Is it possible for you to supply:

            • What Builder are you using? (Ant 1.7? Maven 3? etc.)
            • What test framework is it running? (JUnit 3? TestNG?)
            • Is it possible to attach the XML output of the file with the skipped tests?

            If you don't want these information in the issue, feel free to ping me directly at mark@atlassian.com

            Cheers,

            Mark C

            MarkC added a comment - Miro, tests failed due to an exception From our internal tests that fail with an exception generally gets marked with an ERROR and does get picked up by Bamboo. We'd originally decided to skip the skipped tests since we didn't think them to be important. If tests that failed with an Exception are being skipped, then this certainly more critical. Is it possible for you to supply: What Builder are you using? (Ant 1.7? Maven 3? etc.) What test framework is it running? (JUnit 3? TestNG?) Is it possible to attach the XML output of the file with the skipped tests? If you don't want these information in the issue, feel free to ping me directly at mark@atlassian.com Cheers, Mark C

            We just started using Bamboo and ran into this same problem. I'm amazed a critical issues like this has been open since 2007.

            In our case tests failed due to an exception, but Bamboo does not pick that up and shows the build as succesfull. That pretty much defeats on of the reasons for having bamboo. If folks have to manually review the build log every time, what the piont of using Bamboo?

            Miro Lehky [Metron] added a comment - We just started using Bamboo and ran into this same problem. I'm amazed a critical issues like this has been open since 2007. In our case tests failed due to an exception, but Bamboo does not pick that up and shows the build as succesfull. That pretty much defeats on of the reasons for having bamboo. If folks have to manually review the build log every time, what the piont of using Bamboo?

            Our situation is for the "third" category (the addition of a grey color?) is:

            For builds, sometimes it is not the software being built that is the problem, but part of the actual build/release system.

            For tests, again for integration/system tests, services like the testdb fails occasionally, so we skip related tests but want to show them as incomplete. The SUT had no opportunity to be tested.

            Niall Stapley added a comment - Our situation is for the "third" category (the addition of a grey color?) is: For builds, sometimes it is not the software being built that is the problem, but part of the actual build/release system. For tests, again for integration/system tests, services like the testdb fails occasionally, so we skip related tests but want to show them as incomplete. The SUT had no opportunity to be tested.

              Unassigned Unassigned
              f8cbeadd3032 Max Horváth
              Votes:
              14 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              11 Start watching this issue

                Created:
                Updated:
                Resolved: