[#JRA-9350] Investigate and change if possible the rpc plugin to generate document/literal wrapped WSDL

JIRA

Investigate and change if possible the rpc plugin to generate document/literal wrapped WSDL

Created: 13/Feb/06 06:16 PM Updated: 06/Jun/08 08:00 AM

Component/s:

Remote API (SOAP & XML-RPC)

Affects Version/s:

3.5

Fix Version/s:

None

Time Tracking:

Not Specified

Issue Links:

Reference

This issue relates to:

JRA-12152 SOAP is incompatible with Axis2 and Xfire

Participants:	Dylan Etkin [Atlassian], Kenny MacLeod, Martin Rothbaum, Patrice Lamarque, Raphael Parree and Vojtech Habarta
Since last comment:	18 weeks, 2 days ago
Support reference count:	3
Labels:

Description

« Hide

Currently we use Axis to generate our WSDL, by default Axis generated WSDL in the rpc/encoded style. This style is not WS-1 supported. A more popular style that is supported by many frameworks is the document/literal wrapped style WSDL. The only issue that may exist for us is that the document/literal wrapped style WSDL does not natively support overloaded methods, of which we use a ton. It may be the case that Axis handles this when generating the stubs, we need to find out. We also need to find out how, if at all, this will effect existing SOAP clients. There is a good doc about the different WSDL encoding styles here.

All

Comments

Work Log

Change History

Sort Order:

[ Permlink | « Hide ]

Patrice Lamarque added a comment - 27/Aug/06 06:14 AM

I voted for this one and simply want to let you know that using rpc/encoded prevents from being used by JBossWS and XFire.

[ Permlink | « Hide ]

Kenny MacLeod added a comment - 22/Sep/06 12:21 PM

The JAX-WS reference implementation also does not work with this, for the same reason - rpc/encoded is a dead duck.

[ Permlink | « Hide ]

Vojtech Habarta added a comment - 30/Nov/06 01:05 PM

I am repeating here what I wrote when I reported this request:

JIRA SOAP Service uses rpc/encoded in WSDL which is not supported by JAX-WS 2.0. It also doesn't work with Microsoft WCF.
This is not only Sun's and Microsoft's decision, rpc/encoded is also against WS-I Basic Profile.
Please provide JIRA SOAP Service with document/literal/wrapped WSDL.

[ Permlink | « Hide ]

Martin Rothbaum added a comment - 01/Feb/07 08:03 PM

Escalated to Adriaan Rootman at HP. Awaiting response.

[ Permlink | « Hide ]

Martin Rothbaum added a comment - 01/Feb/07 08:05 PM

Please ignore comment above - added to wrong issue (infact wrong Jira instance :-o)

[ Permlink | « Hide ]

Raphael Parree added a comment - 06/Jun/08 08:00 AM

Any developments in this area? JAX-WS and JAXB is now part of JDK so many people would probably like to use JAX-WS as apposed to tools that support the deprecated rpc-encoded style web services.